- Nov 27, 2005http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/articles/2005/11/06/the_way_we_were/?page=full
may ask for registration; here's the relevant para
Reviewing the "lavish new Norton anthology of children's literature":
' There is, first of all and most balefully, literature written by adults to
instruct children-that is, to educate or lead them out of childhood (the
root meaning of educate is "to lead out"). But unless the pill is
well-sugared, as in, for example, C.S. Lewis's "Chronicles of Narnia"
series, no one-neither adults nor children-wants to read literature that has
this kind of design on its readers. Lewis himself (who is not in the
anthology) is a perfect example of a writer whom adults enjoy less than
children do-because we see more of what he is up to, and often don't like
it. Lewis, one senses, wants to make children feel guilty and depraved, to
see themselves as wicked-for example, in "The Lion, the Witch, and the
Wardrobe," where children are supposed to recognize Edmund's selfishness and
greed in themselves. But fortunately they don't, and we can take pleasure in
their insouciant obliviousness to this moralizing. '