12480Re: [mythsoc] Newest Greenman Review
- Jul 7, 2004
>But nothing but ignorance can excuse Gray Walker's claim that J.E.A.Now, now. Not everyone agrees on what is a good reference guide. And Grey never claimed to be a Tolkien expert, just
>Tyler's _Complete Tolkien Companion_ is the one essential reference book on
>Tolkien. There are many worse ones, but there's one that outshines it as
>the sun does the moon. It's Robert Foster's _Complete Guide to
>Middle-earth._ Has Walker even heard of it? It's the book on Christopher
>Tolkien's reference shelf, and that should be recommendation enough for anyone.
a fan. What's more I suggest that simply because Christopher has something on his shelf doesn't mean that everyone
else should have it too.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>