10910Re: Faithfulness to Tolkien (was Re: [mythsoc] Re: My own RotK review)
- Jan 2, 2004On Jan 2, 2004, at 10:13 PM, David Bratman wrote:
> An author is free to be vague or incomplete in physical descriptionsA film-maker would have just as much of an option to "fill in the
> of persons, places, and things; a film-maker doesn't have that option.
blanks" as a reader does, in places where Tolkien provides no
description in the book. So again, I fail to see how one could possibly
need information not in the book in order to be faithful to the book.
> It was his script that sucked.Boy howdy.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>