17997RE: Magnetic chuck plans posted to files
- Mar 3, 2014Poker -
Yes, I am doubtful that today's common magnet wire is up to having hot babbitt poured over it.
I imagine the intent for the babbitt was two-fold:
1) prevent the coil windings rubbing off the enamel due to energizing/de-energizing cycles, eventually short-circuiting the coil, and ending up in deep mischief
2) provide a conduction path to help remove waste heat
I am just a hack mechanical engineer from the northwoods, so I may be all wet on those suppositions. If anyone has other thoughts, I'm all ears.
I think small transformer windings are still dunked in varnish, aren't they? That might be a cheap way to deal with the first, but not the second, consideration.
The second criterion needs something which conducts heat well. There are several low temperature alloys ("Cerro Bend" is a typical brand name), some of which melt well below the boiling point of water, others at quite a bit higher temperatures. One or another might be well-suited on other accounts, but these alloys aren't cheap, so that dog won't likely hunt. When used for their intended purposes (filling thin-walled tubing prior to bending to prevent wall collapse, potting small parts for machining, etc.) the alloy is re-used indefinitely, and the cost is amortized. But, nothing in my garage amortizes, anyway - though I do get a bit of surface rust on stuff from time to time (I know, oxidize-amortize, not such a good joke).
There are special thermal epoxies available, used for bonding thermal probes to surfaces, but again, they aren't inexpensive.
What about the "Lab Metal" and similar metal-filled epoxy products? Ever had any experience with those as a heat sink? I wonder if JBWeld mixed with powdered aluminum (the stuff used to make metalic paint), would do the trick? Vacuum de-gassing and/or vibration to remove air bubbles, perhaps? Or metal-filled silicone? Tub caulk is pretty cheap from big box stores...
- << Previous post in topic