Hi G --
I don't think Judi is saying at all
"just do nothing and believe you are already
I think she is saying you must come to the end
of your rope, the end of your adventure and
process of becoming, of getting somewhere else,
other than you are.
Not saying, "I am fine as I am," but looking
into what is going on when you attempt to
say that -- what you are doing when you
try to reassure yourself like that.
Her critique points out, to me, that
often "meditation practice" becomes a kind
of placebo, someting to believe in so as
to feel good about yourself eventually
She wants to undermine this kind of complacency,
which is really a kind of supression.
Meditation as formal practice easily lends itself
to supression and belief that the status quo
is working just fine.
She is saying truth is here when the status quo
is shaken to its roots and drops away.
I feel she is talking about the heart of meditation,
which formal practices presented by organizations
Gautama didn't say, "I am going to meditate real
good, because meditation is good for your health
and well-being, and I want to be healthy and feel
Gautama did say, "I am going to sit here and not
leave until I know, truly know directly. Nothing
else matters to me, my will to live and thrive
has no value, my family and power don't matter,
there is just nothing else I can possibly
do at this point."
The suggestions, rationales, practices, and so on
that various authorities had offered him, and
which he had mastered were of no avail.
Similar indications are shown by such as Lao Tzu,
Jesus, I'm sure many others, but I don't
So, for me, Judi is indicating that the heart of
meditation has nothing to do with accepting
what someone else tells you meditation practice
is and should be. And she's not saying just
do what you feel like doing, don't worry,
you're enlightened already.
You can't know what already always is the case,
until you're attempt to provide other things
which you want to be the case drops away.
That attempt can be "I'm going to just be,
and enjoy that I'm already enlightened,"
or "I'm going to meditate real good, so
I can learn more and more about who I am --
isn't this great?"
The heart of meditation is utter self-confrontation
that is direct, that is the falling away of
the unreal anchoring, that someone else can't
When you talk about your experience, it seems you're
sometimes saying similar things.
Frankly, the outward differences of form of how you
teach and how Judi teaches doesn't matter as much to me as
the heart of knowing, in which self-deceit
breaks apart ...
You deserve a break today,
> G: understanding as you like to call it .... or knowing as i call
> happens in an instant .... first the ground is prepared ... the
> seed is planted .... it ripens.... and falls off of the
> for myself it was in a split second ... it was a known that
> out all the known abouts and concepts ... but without having
> come to a stilled place and absolute surrender it wouldn't have
> happened.... and that surrender wouldn't have taken place
> unless a number a fallacys were pulled away first.... that
> happened through meditation - one pointed focus - being in the
> moment - vipassana - then self enquiry....
> one can walk around saying it is already here and there is
> nothing to do until they are blue in the face and it won't change a
> thing nor awaken them .... you may postulate that it does ...
> you can just accept what is here and still be trapped in the
> delusions of your own creation... it is sad that you are so
> vehement against everything except your view that one should
> simply just give up and accept where they are.... there is a vast
> differance in just giving up and in surrender....
> surrender comes sometimes after years of yes the dreaded
> word *practice* ..... there are many many roads and paths to
> enlightenment ... not one ... just as there are vast amounts of
> differances and variables in seekers and their conditioned
> awarenesses.... the miss judi farm of beating someone into
> submission while attractive to some is not the only alternative....
> there are many ways and means ... what works for one is a
> hinderance to another.... the thing is to find the keys that
> your awareness and ability to surrender to what IS ... the key to
> unlock the door to walk through and leave the ego "I" behind with
> it's resulting dramas and sufferings.....
> it is easy to sit on the judi throne of disdain and continue to
> the littany over and over again.... that there is nothing to
> and no where to go.... Wonderful it might have worked for
> i don't say that it didn't.... but clearly it does not work for
> or else there wouldn't be so many methods and paths that are
> quite viable and remain in place simply because yes they can
> and do work......
> now how many nay sayer posts can you get out of this one.....
> enjoy your circle judi .... watch and around and around she will
> go..... the punch and judi show of disdane for anything
> except just *Wake Up* ..... if it were that easy judi then
> the people that are not doing anything would already be
> free from suffering... but the fact that they are not disproves
> your path of simply do nothing.....
> shanti om ...g...