- well i dont know but i think u r not clr about the prop main concept...anyway, actually the Fs used in mine or nasa vi's isnt actually F alover... it is changing...if u have diff to und it, then u may use F1, F2... and use F1/F2 = a1/a2...anyway, i don't know yet whether the proofs below r OK or not, but (actually i donnt have sufficient time to go over them) i think the 3D method is okMahbub
wrote:*Fahim <fahim_com@...>*Nasa vai,

apnar mail er >> and g(a=a2) is a fn of a.<< line er mane bughlam na. would u plz expand it?

ar ekta bapar, >> F is prop to a provided b is const. that means k is k(b1), ie a fn of b<< keno hobe bughlam na?

Shanto vai,

apnar soln ta thik moto bughlam na. ami apnar graph theory niye soln ta paisi. kintu ei soln tao bughte chai.

amar somossa gula dekhen:

1. >>so F is prop to a => F = ka. so by increasing k times it came to a2 state say.<<

apni "F is prop to a" bolsen kintu "a" er jaygay "a1" thakar kotha.

2. jodi F prop to a1 hoy tahole F=ka1. ekhon a1 ke k times increase korle ta a2 te keno asbe thik bughlam na. a1 ke k times increase manei k*a1. tahole apnar kotha mote k*a1=a2 hobe.

orthat F=a2 hobe. eita ki somvob? (nasa vaio mone goy eita bolte chaisen).

3. >>now, keep a2 fixed that means a is const. move from b1 to b2.<<

a2 fixed naki a1 fixed?

4. >>so from(a1,b1) state it came to (a2,b2) state by k*g times. that means by const and these. so, F is prop to ab.<<

kintu tara orthat "a" ar "b" gun akare thakbe ken?

hope u would ans.

take care.

good bye.

FAHIMwrote:*Nasa <nasarouf@...>*correction: you *cannot* assume the equality since no such thing was implied.

On 4/30/06,**Nasa**<nasarouf@... > wrote:i think you are forgetting something

F is prop to a provided b is const.

that means k is k(b1), ie a fn of b. there may be different k's at different values for b. k(b1) and k(b2) may not necessarily be equal. you assume the equality since no such thing was implied.

and g(a=a2) is a fn of a.

now do the proof from start.

nasaOn 4/29/06,**mahbubul hasan**< shanto86@...> wrote:assa, dhoro, F is prop to a when b const, and prop to b when a const.Now, say u will change a from a1 to a2, and similarly b1, b2.so say at first keep the system const at b1, and move a1 to a2.so F is prop to a => F = ka. so by increasing k times it came to a2 state say.now, keep a2 fixed that means a is const. move from b1 to b2.F = gb. it came to this is state by g times.so from(a1,b1) state it came to (a2,b2) state by k*g times. that means by const and these. so, F is prop to ab.shanto vai,

ami onek chesta korei math_club e ei somossa ta pathaisi. dekhseni to ekhon porjonto keu mathematical proof dite pare ni. sobai antorikotar sathe chesta korsen. so, would u plz give me the soln?

thank u all.

FAHIMwrote:*mahbubul hasan < shanto86@...>*are eta k to oi vabei proman kora jay! valo moto chinta koro!i know the rule. but what i dont know is the mathematical prove.

FAHIMwrote:*mahbubul hasan < shanto86@...>*well... think in this way, u will change both a and b.but first u will change a keeping b fixed, say u moved from a1 to a2.then u will change from b1 to b2, keeping a fixed.it will obey that rule.amar somossatar somadhan ki keu i dibe na?

>>i know it is really ridiculous ask this kind of question. but really cant understand it. look at my prb:

can u prove that mathematically:

if A is_proportional_to a [when b is constant]

and A is_proportional_to b [when a is constant]

then A is_proportional_to (a*b) [when a & b are not constant]<<

it is the most common thing in proportion. it has used in the newton's law of gravitation to get the equation. aro onek jaigay tei er babohar ase. kintu keu somadhan dilona ken bughlam na.

Hope u'll b interested.

FAHIM

Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. PC-to-Phone calls for ridiculously low rates.

Blab-away for as little as 1ï¿½/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using Yahoo! Messenger with Voice.

Blab-away for as little as 1ï¿½/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using Yahoo! Messenger with Voice.

Yahoo! Mail goes everywhere you do. Get it on your phone.

Get amazing travel prices for air and hotel in one click on Yahoo! FareChaseBlab-away for as little as 1ï¿½/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using Yahoo! Messenger with Voice.`SPONSORED LINKS``Math``Math teacher resource``Mathematics``Math teacher``Math problem solving``Math problem`

`YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS``Visit your group "math_club" on the web.`

`To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:`

math_club-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

`Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.`

Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1¢/min.

How low will we go? Check out Yahoo! Messengers low PC-to-Phone call rates. - "If,

A is proportional to b [when c constant]

A is proportional to c [when b constant]

then we get,

A is proportional to bc [when nothing is constant]"

long ago i asked for proofing this. but didnt get satisfactory ans. now i have a beautiful soln. try to prove it.

FAHIM

Sponsored Link

Mortgage rates near 39yr lows. $420,000 Mortgage for $1,399/mo - Calculate new house payment