Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

2191Re: [lxx] Example of Significantly Interpretive "translation"

Expand Messages
  • philippe guillaume
    Feb 13, 2007
      How about Jon 3.4 (40 or 3 days) ?

      On 2/13/07, JavaJedi2 <javajedi2@...> wrote:

      I'm looking for an example in the LXX where the translator either
      a) clearly did not understand the Hebrew, or b) better still, clearly
      changed the meaning from the extant Hebrew textx. Long ago, I worked
      on the Fourth Servant Song and thought I'd remembered that Isa 53:7-8
      in the LXX looked to me like the translator did not understand the
      Hebrew text very well but last night in looking at the NASB of Isa
      53:7-8 and Brenton on the same passage, perhaps my original
      assessment, based upon reading the Hebrew and Greek myslf, was
      overstated. They seem pretty close in these translations at least.

      So does anyone know of a glaring example of where the translator
      not only was not woodenly literal, as in Genesis, but clearly doing
      interpretation (leaving aside the acknowledged fact that all
      translation involves interpretation)? Thanks.

      Ken Litwak

      Dr Philippe Guillaume
      Stelserstrasse 478A
      CH-7220 SCHIERS
      Tel. +81 330 34 37
    • Show all 5 messages in this topic