Lit & Entertaiment Culture
- Thank you for the correction.
What I should have said is that liturgy leaders are not
I think that among the ways we can describe US society is to
say that we are an entertainment culture. We have more free
time than any other culture in history. Sports are
entertainment not participatory. News has become
entertainment. In the same way as it happened with the
news, I see entertainment values assumed without question in
so much liturgical planning and performance. That includes
such things as pushing for variety and the newest or latest
thing. It includes performances which draw attention to
themselves instead of conveying text to the assembly.
Would anyone like to contribute other items of entertainment
values infiltrating liturgy?
St. Louis, Missouri
Bad liturgy is always the result
of bad planning and sloppy execution.
It doesn't matter what the rite is.
St. Philip's Church, Toronto
James O'Regan wrote:
> Tom (et al) wrote and I snipped:
> > Liturgy leaders are not performers, although they definitely
> > need and often lack performance skills, nor are they
> > curators of cultural treasures.
> To say that liturgical leaders are not performes is
> simply not useful. In fact, if one says that these leaders
> need "performance skills" then one is saying that these
> leaders are, in fact, performers. They are not actors
> because they are not in a play. It is really quite simple
> and need not bother anyone needlessly.
> If one sees these leaders as performers then there is a
> wealth of help for them. Liturgical leaders do not need
> leadership skills, they need performance skills. They
> need the type of performance skills that works in this
> scenario: an occasion of a single performer speaking
> an alien text before witnesses, and occasionally
> speaking these texts with witnesses and in response to
> witnesses. And occasionally speaking their own words,
> but, by and large, speaking someone else's words.
> James O'Regan
- James asked:
> could you put them and the ms on methodology in the files for this groupRegardless of acceptance, my bank manager-account and She-
> or on your own website?
Who-Must-Be-Obeyed insist on commercializing all that I do
per projects since I am not funded in any way. Ergo, a MS
ought to come along within the year as an eBook on Amazon. If
the journals do publish, I'll post the bibliography.
Tom's list is very good and simply by asking how each can
physically and actually happen, one is very close to anything
that I have been researching: how does it (whatever "it" is)
work? Not what do people or the Church (has always said) say
about "it." By examining how any claim for liturgy actually
works, and that means also finding the right questions to ask,
one is on the right track, an effective track and a useful track.