Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Los Angeles Wants to "Reconstitute" Pioneering High Sch ool Despite Major Gains By Joseph Zeccola

Expand Messages
  • Ed Pearl
    Hi. Still waiting for the Earthlink folks in the sky to return to work and me, to send out my regular emailings. In lieu of that, please do pass this on to
    Message 1 of 1 , Dec 28, 2012
      Hi. Still waiting for the Earthlink folks in the sky to return to work and
      me, to send out my regular emailings.
      In lieu of that, please do pass this on to teachers, parents and lots of
      other concerned folks, especiall in L.A.

      From: info@... [mailto:info@...]
      Sent: Friday, December 28, 2012 4:20 AM
      To: epearlag@...
      Subject: ZNet Daily Commentary: Los Angeles Wants to "Reconstitute"
      Pioneering High School Despite Major Gains By Joseph Zeccola

      > zspace


      Los Angeles Wants to "Reconstitute" Pioneering High School Despite Major

      December 28, 2012 By Joseph Zeccola

      cx-2BrttTugzdKni0ACBk-3D> Zeccola's ZSpace Page / ZSpace

      How should management respond when a group of union teachers pilots a
      nationally recognized reform model at a historically troubled school,
      working side by side with parents, students, community organizations, and
      academics, and makes big gains in the first year?

      If you're the Los Angeles school district, you fire all the teachers and
      start over.

      The district has announced plans to "transform" Crenshaw High, one of only
      four majority-African-American schools in the district, into three new
      magnet schools for the 2013-14 school year. Magnet schools traditionally
      serve specialized student interests (such as medical magnet, arts magnet)
      and enrollment is usually based on application, though the district claims
      all students who would ordinarily be eligible to Crenshaw will be admitted.

      More importantly, a magnet conversion allows the district to dismiss all the
      teachers and force them to reapply for their jobs. The conversion would
      disrupt the reforms that have been implemented at Crenshaw through its Small
      Learning Community structure.

      When others schools in the district have undergone such conversions, more
      than half the teachers were not rehired. Dubious hiring decisions often
      exclude veteran teachers and outspoken union activists.

      But students and community members, who helped create the school's popular
      and successful new teaching model, are rallying with teachers to defend

      Grassroots Education Reform

      Union teachers (members of United Teachers Los Angeles, UTLA), parents,
      community members, and academics collaborated to create Crenshaw's Extended
      Learning Cultural Model and began to implement it last year under the
      leadership of the school's then-interim principal, University of Southern
      California Professor Sylvia Rousseau.

      A prestigious foundation grant allowed Crenshaw to pilot the model at two of
      the school's small learning communities, which allow for magnet-type focus
      and personalization without requiring students to apply for admission.

      The program linked classroom teaching relevant to the students' experiences
      to work and internships in the community. For instance, students worked on
      food surveys at area stores to gauge the availability of healthy food,
      relative to the rest of Los Angeles. They also did community interviews to
      create a portrait of the America they live in, based on a book called Our

      Teachers designed collaborative lessons across subjects. All students used
      the same set of school-wide data, looking at those data in different ways in
      each of their content classes.

      The model was explicitly political, asking teachers to learn from and
      embrace their students' cultures. One of Crenshaw's goals is to create
      learners who are able to contribute to their neighborhoods.

      Both parents and teachers did specialized work to support the model. The
      parents received "intentional civility" training as part of the plan, while
      the teachers received training and did research on how to teach students who
      are not academically fluent in English, are socioeconomically disadvantaged,
      or are students of color.

      The program required teachers to spend hours of extra time each month
      learning, collaborating, and reflecting on their craft-but the results were

      Wanting to Be in School

      "There was an enormous jump in kids wanting to be in the classroom," said
      Lewis King, a UCLA professor of clinical psychiatry, who helped lead the

      The program's success showed up on California's statewide standardized
      tests, where Crenshaw met all but one of its goals in 2012.

      Special education students made huge gains. African-American students scored
      higher than at six of the other seven high schools in South Los Angeles. On
      the high school exit exams, Crenshaw saw increased scores for all students
      in English and a 300 percent increase in math scores for students not fluent
      in English.

      The turnaround is remarkable for a school that briefly lost its
      accreditation in 2005 and had struggled to make consistent progress on test
      scores ever since.

      Punished for Success

      But instead of praising Crenshaw's teachers for these strides, the district
      informed them they would all be dismissed and invited to re-apply for their

      In a letter to faculty, Superintendent John Deasy blamed four years of "less
      than adequate progress in the achievement of Crenshaw's students."

      Deasy didn't mention how the district played a role in creating those
      problems-subjecting Crenshaw to years of unstable leadership before
      Principal Rousseau arrived.

      The school had endured 33 administrative changes since 2005, including five
      principals, when Crenshaw was stripped of its accreditation. When the
      Western Association of Schools and Colleges visited again in 2012, its
      report said that its Visiting Committee (VC) was "shocked and frustrated" at
      Crenshaw's turnover.

      The committee was impressed with Rousseau's leadership, however, reporting
      that she had "captured the loyalty, support and respect of every student,
      teacher, staff member and parent that the VC met during the visit. The
      entire school is now working together as a team."

      Special education teacher Christine Lewis agreed. "She was tireless," Lewis
      said of Rousseau. "She met with us more than any other principal has met
      with teachers."

      Lewis looked forward to Rousseau's continued guidance in the 2012-13 school
      year, as a coach or consultant to the school. This did not happen.

      "It was as if she never existed," Lewis said. "The extended learning model
      has disappeared."


      At a Crenshaw community meeting December 11, parents and students vented
      their anger at the district for abruptly halting the promising program after
      just one year and imposing "transformation" on the school-all without
      consulting teachers, parents, students, or community members.

      "Magnets are not going to solve the whole problem," said Crenshaw
      tenth-grader Tanness Walker. "The teachers here connect with their students.
      If they don't get their jobs back, we'll have to start all over with new

      Lewis agreed. "I have put a lot of my own time and money into making myself
      a better teacher," she said. "I took out student loans so that I could get
      better content knowledge in math.

      "My fear is that the teachers who will come in will only give the kids the
      minimum and not really expect much of these kids."

      Crenshaw graduate Irvin Alvarado said he was the product of his teachers'

      "If it wasn't for those teachers, I wouldn't be in college today," Alvarado
      said. "All that the teachers did, they did by the skin of their teeth. They
      did it with the barest of resources."

      Superintendent Deasy did not attend the meeting. District leaders stood
      impassively behind bookshelves as the new principal tried to explain to
      frustrated parents why their school was going to be radically altered.

      King warned the magnet conversion would create "enormous distrust."

      "You cannot build on a sand bed," he said. "You have to build on a rock. You
      have to build on the strength of the community, on what the community
      already knows."

      Resisting Top-Down Restructuring

      The hopeful news is that the Crenshaw community is fighting back. Parent
      leaders are systematically organizing more parents into the movement.
      They're holding house meetings, gathering petition signatures, and sending
      representatives to larger meetings with teachers, students, community
      members, black clergy, and more.

      Students are organizing independently, through student government and the
      groups Taking Action and the Coalition for Educational Justice. Recent
      alumni are assisting the organizing efforts via social media.

      A coalition of community organizations has held a series of town halls and
      helped parents and students focus their plan of action. And Crenshaw's
      teachers and staff are backing them up by bringing union leaders and
      rank-and-file members into the battle-turning out supporters for meetings,
      writing articles on teacher email lists, and developing a plan to support
      Crenshaw in the coming year.

      "All of our union brothers and sisters should stand behind us, because if
      they can do that at Crenshaw, they can do that anywhere," Lewis said. "You
      cannot transform a school without the teachers."

      UTLA is pushing the district school board to formally support Crenshaw's
      Extended Learning Cultural Model and to stop the restructuring.

      The activists are also questioning the legality of Deasy's restructuring by
      meeting with regulators.

      Crenshaw has a strong ally in nearby Dorsey High, another majority-African-
      American school, which has been facing the threat of reconstitution itself
      for over a year. While the Dorsey community won't know the district's plans
      for their school until early in 2013, they're standing side by side with
      Crenshaw and will fight together for true reform in public education-whether
      that fight is just for Crenshaw or for both schools.

      When Deasy visited the school in November, Lewis said, he called the teacher
      organizing "very divisive." That may have been wishful thinking on Deasy's
      part. The truth is, the organizing is bringing people together-and that
      bodes well for Crenshaw's future.

      Joseph Zeccola is an English and drama teacher in the Los Angeles school
      district. He is also a member of UTLA's board of directors and of PEAC:
      Progressive Educators for Action, a rank-and-file caucus within UTLA.


      From: Z
      Net - The Spirit Of Resistance Lives

      To view commentaries online go here:
      Comment on this commentary:


      No virus found in this message.
      Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
      Version: 2013.0.2805 / Virus Database: 2637/5975 - Release Date: 12/20/12
      Internal Virus Database is out of date.

      [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.