Count the natural debt, too-CSE's Fortnightly Bulletin (Dec 1, 2011)
CSE's Fortnightly News Bulletin (December 1, 2011)
The Durban conference began this fortnight. It will be important to track developments there so that we can collectively keep pushing the world to take more effective and just actions on climate change.
CSE will be doing the following to keep you informed:
1. A few of us will be at Durban, tracking events there and reporting live. You can find our contacts in durban and our reports at http://cseindia.org/content/durban
2. The ministry of environment and forests (MoEF) and CSE are organising a side event -- 'The imperative of equity for an effective climate agreement'. Environment minister Jayanthi Natarajan will be chairing it. For details, kindly visit http://cseindia.org/node/3453. For all our friends in Durban, please do come, we need your support.
There's more happening at CSE. Our Renewable Energy Portal -- http://re.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in -- is now up and running. In Down To Earth, we bring you a critique of the NREGA programme. And we also have other stories, activities and courses...
To subscribe to this newsletter or other newsletters, please click on : http://cseindia.my2.in/cseindia/?p=subscribe
To unsubscribe from this newsletter, just click
If you have any questions or concerns about newsletter subscription, please contact Vikas Khanna at vikas@...
EDITORIAL: Count the natural debt, too
by Sunita Narain
Now that Europe’s debt crisis is unfolding all around us, shouldn’t we question why the world is determined to live beyond its means and not worry how it sabotages our common future? The debt crisis is a mere symptom of a deeper malaise. The fact is that countries, private companies and individual households can run only if they can borrow against their assets and hope that the debt will grow slower than the value of their asset. Most financial analysts will now tell you that this business is doomed because of the Ponzi scheme nature of the loan business, where borrowing is used to speculate to get more loans and so repayment becomes difficult and over time impossible.
But this analysis is myopic as it misses the real nature of the problem: economic growth, as we see it, means living beyond one’s means. The cost of development has risen to such an extent that nothing is possible without loans or subsidy. Take agriculture in the debt-strapped rich world. It’s a fact that growing food is now so expensive that it needs huge subsidy from the public exchequer to be feasible (if not profitable). In 2010, the European Union spent some US $70-80 billion (47 per cent of its budget) on direct payments to farmers to keep them in business.
The story is the same in other parts of the developed world. But what is not explained is that this subsidy is needed because of rising costs of land, labour, other inputs and environmental safeguards. Growing food is expensive indeed.
Same with education: In the US, student debt has risen sharply—from $80 billion in 1999 to anywhere between $550 and $800 billion by June 2011, according to US Federal Bank estimates. Now as unemployment looms, loan delinquency is on the rise because graduates do not have money to pay back. By June 2011, student loan delinquency was almost as high as the credit card non-repayment rate of 12 per cent. But what is not discussed is why the cost of education, particularly in the for-profit college industry, is increasing and how sustainable is this rise in the long run. The education story holds for other sectors as well. Rising health costs mean higher costs of insurance or lack of medical support for most. The list goes on.
The fact is that cost of development is high. It makes money for a few but is unaffordable for most, because it is the exchequer that has to subsidise this development. This, in turn, increases public debt to crippling levels.
What is not even discussed in the context of the current debt crisis is the other debt, which has been accumulated for growth. Each country’s release of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere has reduced the cost of its growth. It is a loan from nature for economic development. But the cumulative emissions of a country—one country, the US, has contributed 26 per cent to the stock of emissions between 1950 and 2007—must be added to the cost of growth. In the case of natural debt, economies borrow the assimilative capacity of the environment by releasing waste gases faster than they can be removed naturally. This natural debt is similar to the financial debt of a nation, because it is a loan from nature taken to grow faster and at lower costs.
The combined cost of growth is evident for all to see. The financial debt is leading banks and economies to collapse, while the natural debt is taking the climate to catastrophe, adding to costs of economic repair and increasing the costs of growth itself.
This growth model should be on the line when the world meets to discuss climate change. The financial debt crisis is linked to the natural debt crisis and this is the real cost of growth that the world cannot afford.
Question should also be raised whether the still-emerging world can afford this costly growth model. Remember, the cost of energy is higher today than it was when the now-developed world was building its infrastructure for development. Remember also that infrastructure in the emerging economies has not even been built. Financial loans are crippling the developed world now, when its development infrastructure is more or less in place; when its cost is to maintain this infrastructure or to regenerate or improve its efficiency or environmental performance. Remember also, its population growth is stable or even negative. This does add to costs that have to be paid to ageing segments, but it does mean that it has fewer or equal numbers of people to provide for. But our world needs development that has to reach millions of people—and millions more will be added to its populations in the years to come.
It is time the world asked some really tough questions and looked for new answers. Can we go ahead with this unaffordable and unsustainable model of growth? Can we not do better than to tinker with the same economic systems that only bring more pain and more systems collapse? It is time we joined the dots—the financial debt and the natural debt—to look for the answers that matter.
Post your comments on this editorial online at http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/count-natural-debt-too
MORE FROM DOWN TO EARTH
- Cover Story: A million opportunities lost
The rural employment programme took unprecedented strides in creating water conservation structures across the country, What went wrong?
- Special Report: Farmers in tech trap
Cotton cultivators are on a seed and pesticide treadmill that is draining them of traditional skills
- Special Report: Trade barred
Countries protect their renewable energy equipment. Exporting nations see it as trade barrier
- Special Report: Leprosy looms
Latest survey dismisses government’s claims of disease elimination
- Features: Biogas rediscovered
Innovative Vidarbha farmers make biogas plants viable
- News: Blatant lies for laterite
Andhra pollution control board holds public hearing for a project in Schedule Five area
- News: India set for new nuclear age
Hunt on for the site of the world’s first thorium-based plant. But is it safe?
- News: Democracy under surveillance
West Bengal bureaucrats to monitor panchayat institutions, implement their decisions
- S&T: Dwarfed by climate change
Animals, plants stunt as global warming alters metabolism
- S&T: Cure for yellow stream
Green algae can revitalise streams poisoned with mine acids
- Crosscurrent: Don’t just cash in on tigers
Nature-based tourism: from rhetoric to reality
- 20 years of DTE - Displaced for development
1992 was the year of India’s economic liberalisation. Down To Earth had warned that development or conservation had to be people-centric. Edited excerpts
- Column: Patently absurd
DRUG AFFORDABILITY TEST
- South Asia - Forests for people
Newly democratic Bhutan pushes community forestry to tackle rural poverty
Down To Earth is now on Facebook and Twitter. Do follow us, share, comment, and discuss
and stay in constant touch with our reporters on www.facebook.com/down2earthindia and twitter@downtoearthindia.
- South Asia: Lost in woods
Environmentalists see red over Bangladesh's wildlife bill
- South Asia: Founder of Sri Lanka's sarvodaya movement turns 80
- Web Special: Tamil Nadu's temple tanks hold key to water recharge
- Web Special: ‘Commercial interest cannot drive lake conservation in Bengaluru’
- Reporter's Diary: A hard rain’s falling
Sayantan Bera tells the story of a man and a state, paralysed inside the remote islands of Sundarbans
- Reporter's Diary: Tiger tour operators' incidental love: tribals
Kumar Sambhav Shrivastava's take on tour operators' claim that tourism in core areas of reserves is good for tribals
- Blog: Kingfisher and cronies
Government bailouts planned for Vijay Mallya’s floundering airline are proof of how well crony capitalism is working in India
- Blog: Four hops on Facebook
We are virtually closer, for good or bad
- Photogallery: A walk through Mangar Bani, a sacred grove near Delhi
On India Environment Portal
CSE has launched the new renewable energy portal aimed at promoting socially just, environmentally sustainable and independent views on RE policies and practices. So utilise the E-forum for posting questions and exchanging your views at http://cseindia.org/forum/20323
Read also the latest photo blogs by our reporters
1. Solar lighting - No time to wait for grid or government
2. Uttarakhand hills with solar power don’t prefer ‘taar wali bijli’
You are invited to be our partner and contribute to the RE portal. So, if you come across interesting renewable energy projects, case studies or stories, the RE portal can be a platform to spread the message (through articles, photos, videos, blogs etc.)
For more details contact Kiran Pandey at kiran@..., kirandwi@...
Sub-portal on South Asia and Sustainable Development: Provides in-depth information through news, reports, analysis, opinions and events, linked to other
key institutions and websites etc. Please do contribute studies, reports, court orders etc, especially from our neighbouring countries in the South Asian
India Environment Portal is now on Facebook and Twitter. Do follow us, share, comment, and discuss and stay in constant touch with us on
http://www.facebook.com/pages/indiaenvironmentportal/228015872817 and http://www.twitter.com/indiaenvportal
CSE Environment Photo Library is online.Follow the link to view our collection http://www.flickr.com/photos/csepictures
For any assistance, please contact kiran@..., kirandw@...
LEARNING WITH CSE
Courses offered by Anil Agarwal Green College
One Month Training Programme on Environment Impact Assessment and Social Impact Assessment
To provide practical exposure to participants with specific reference to Mining, Hydropower, Highways and Industrial and Power Projects.
Date: 16th January – 16th February, 2012
Last Date of Application: 3rd January, 2012
- Environmental and social impacts of development projects
- Environmental and social laws and regulations
- All aspects of EIA/SIA, from theory to practices
- Use of GIS and remote sensing in environment planning and management
- Reviewing EIA reports, identifying strengths and weaknesses
- Post-EIA monitoring
Course contact: SWATI SINGH SAMBYAL
Research Associate- Industry & Environment Unit
Centre for Science and Environment
41, Tughlakabad Institutional Area, New Delhi-110062
Ph: 91-11-2995 5124 / 6110 (Ext. 281); Fax: 91-11-2995 5879
Mobile: 9910496283 Email: swati@...
Training programme on Social Impact Assessment
Capacity building and creating awareness among regulators, developers, NGOs and academicians
Date: December 15-17, 2011
- Exposure to aspects of SIA, from theory to applications
- Integrated approach for addressing SIA and EIA process - from scoping, data collection to impact assessment as well as the role of public consultations
- Knowledge on review of SIA reports and identification of strengths and weaknesses
- Post SIA monitoring
- Procedure for institutional strengthening and capacity building
- Experience sharing on national and international best practices adopted in SIA
Course details: http://www.cseindia.org/content/cse%E2%80%99s-short-term-training-programme-social-impact-assessment
Course contact: Sujit Kumar Singh
Industry & Environment Unit
Centre for Science and Environment
41, Tughlakabad Institutional Area, New Delhi-110062
Ph: 91-11-2995 5124 / 6110 (Ext. 281); Fax: 91-11-2995 5879
Training programme on Domestic Wastewater Treatment and Reuse
A certificate training programme to review the existing wastewater treatment practices and promote decentralised wastewater treatment systems particularly in un-sewered areas to facilitate recycling and reuse of wastewater.
Date: Date:January 18-21,2012
Last date for applying: January 10, 2012
- Water management and status of sewage generation and treatment in India
- Fundamentals of wastewater treatment
- Review of the existing treatment practices
- Decentralized approaches in treating sewage
- New and emerging on site technologies in domestic wastewater treatment
- Water efficient sanitation practices
- Economics of decentralized wastewater treatment systems
- Planning, designing, implementation and monitoring of localized treatment systems
For more information visit : http://cseindia.org/node/2772
Some fellowships for participants from South Asia available.
Course contact: Deblina Dwivedi
Senior Research Associate – Urban Water Programme
Centre for Science and Environment
41, Tughlakabad Institutional Area, New Delhi - 110062
Phone: +91 (011) 29955124/125 , Fax: +91 (011) 29955879
Mob: 9899596661 Email: deblina@...
UPDATES FROM OUR PROGRAMME UNITS
CSE's Green Sense Survey
Test your Green Sense here. It takes hardly 2 minutes, only 10 objective questions, and you get your Green Report card immediately.
Churning Still Water - National conference on lake conservation
CSE is organising a one-day national conference on lake conservation in the last week of January.The objective of the workshop is to set up a network of researchers, NGOs, legal advocates and regulators from India involved in the conservation of urban lakes.
We invite abstracts (not more than 250 words) from researchers, NGOs, faculties, law practicioners, in the areas relevant to lake conservation (and/or threats).
Abstract submission deadline: December 17, 2011
Submissions should be sent to Sushmita at sushmita@...
For further details, please visit http://www.cseindia.org/content/churning-still-water
National Seminar on ‘Decentralised Wastewater Management Practices: Options and Challenges’
The aim of the seminar is to act as a forum to discuss and share experiences regarding the existing and upcoming decentralised sewage treatment concepts and technologies. Abstracts are invited from water experts at national level to present case studies on sustainable wastewater management practices – onsite & offsite.
Date: February 2012
Abstract submission deadline: January 14, 2012
Please send you submissions to Deblina at deblina@...
Fore more details, kindly visit http://www.cseindia.org/node/3276
Jaipur Citizen's Survey: Transport and air quality challenges
CSE's Clean Air Campaign team is organising a citizens’ survey in Jaipur to understand the challenges of air pollution and transportation that the city faces, and identify the way forward.
Would you like to volunteer your participation in the survey? Just fill out a form at http://cseindia.org/node/1190 and send it to us.
For details, please get in touch with Vivek at vivek@...
RainWater Harvesting Technical Support
Every Friday between 2:00 pm to 6:00 pm, CSE provides detailed technical guidance to interested individuals, RWAs and institutions to implement rainwater harvesting. The technical assistance will be provided at CSE’s office at 41, Tughlakabad Institutional Area.
For details, see
Technical advice: Decentralised wastewater treatment systems
Every second and fourth Friday, meet our experts at CSE, 41, Tughlaqabad Institutional Area for guidance on
planning and designing these systems.
For details, contact Deblina at deblina@... or call her on 9899596661.
>From our stores===================================
Books from CSE that you might have missed:
Climate Change and Natural Resources -- A book of activities for environmental education
This is a collection of easy-to-understand-and-do activities for students and teachers, to be done in classrooms and at homes. Do take a look at http://www.gobartimes.org/?q=node/201, or write to Vikas Khanna at vikas@...
Mobility Crisis - Agenda for Action 2011
Our publication on the way cities are being held hostage by rising vehicular traffic, and some thoughts on how to break the gridlock
(Pages 116) PB: Rs 290 / US $12
Challenge of the new ballance
Based on a CSE study of the six most energy/emissions-intensive sectors of the country to determine India's low carbon growth options, this book is a must have for all who are interested in development economics and the way ahead for the country. The six sectors -- power,steel, aluminium, cement, fertilizer and paper & pulp -- together account for an estimated 61.5% of total greenhouse gas emissions in India, excluding emissions from agriculture and waste. Their energy profile is no less intensive...
(Pages 156) PB: Rs.690 / US $39
To order please visit: www.csestore.cse.org.in
Coming soon: Excreta Matters
CSE's 7th State of the India's Environment report on water and wastewater, based on a comprehensive survey of 71 Indian cities.
About this e-mail
You are receiving this newsletter because you have asked to be included in our list, attended a CSE event or requested information.
CSE is an independent, public interest organization that was established in 1982 by Anil Agarwal, a pioneer of India's environmental movement. CSE's mandate is to research, communicate and promote sustainable development with equity, participation and democracy.