Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Anyone ever get a bruised knee bone from doing the JMT? I think I did this year.

Expand Messages
  • Roleigh Martin
    I did fine on my JMT hike for 16 days of hiking but on the 17th and 26th day of hiking the ordinary schedule is to do about 4-5 miles uphill then 10-11 miles
    Message 1 of 1 , Aug 23, 2012
      I did fine on my JMT hike for 16 days of hiking but on the 17th and 26th day of hiking the ordinary schedule is to do about 4-5 miles uphill then 10-11 miles downhill (with the downhill being about 3800 and 6000 feet of descent (respectively descending from Muir Pass and Mt Whitney (the tallest mountain in the 48 contiguous states)).  Each of these two days, my left knee became inflamed and I ended up favoring the right knee to the point it became sore too.  After the Muir Pass descent, the knee quickly recovered in about 5-6 days (I was hiking with a limp though), but after Whitney (which was the final exit day of the full JMT trail), my knees were so sore, that 12 days later (today), I'm still sore (not as much when not using the knee) and slowly handle stairs and walk a little slowly. 

      I should have taken two days apiece to do each long descent and I'd have been in much better shape now (perhaps not have the problem at all).  I did not have this problem prior to the torn knee meniscus issue (which I've reported on earlier and happened July 2, 2011), so I know that the prolotherapy sessions have not healed my knee 100% fully.  I need to continue the treatments and will. I hope I did not worsen my knees because of those two days (particularly the last day).  I feel like I am only about 2.5% better each day so I know it will be probably 1-2 months before I know the full impact.  I was told that prolotherapy treatment for older people (I'm 62) can be  up to 6-9 sessions.  I have had 3 stem cell prolotherapy treatments and 3 standard prolotherapy treatments.  I am going to continue my treatments but have switched clinics to one locally in Avon, CT.  A Dr. Paul Tortland at http://jockdoctors.com -- I think he is as good as the provider who did the stem cell treatment from Chicago.

      I feel like daily I'm getting about 2-3% better so I think in 1-2 months, I'll be back to normal.  I wondered what had happened to me and after some Google Research feel I suffered a non-surface visible knee bone bruise.  I found some interesting links on this:

      "Sometimes the bruise is visible on the skin when other soft tissues are bruised, but the only definitive way to determine if swelling is the result of a bone bruise is with an X-ray. "


      http://www.healio.com/orthopedics/journals/ORTHO/%7B2830F54D-9F5D-4040-9297-BFD53E386488%7D/Association-of-Knee-Bone-Bruise-Frequency-With-Time-Postinjury-and-Type-of-Soft-Tissue-Injury  (embedded link if your email destroyed this long link)
      "Magnetic resonance imaging of 1546 patients revealed bone bruises in 19% of patients without an associated meniscal or ligamentous injury. For those patients presenting with at least one meniscoligamentous injury, the frequency of bruising was 60% at 0 to 4 weeks, 42% at 4 to 10 weeks, and 31% at 10 to 26 weeks postinjury."

      "RESULTS. In 80 patients, 157 bone bruises were found. The estimated median healing time was 42.1 weeks. Healing was prolonged in patients having a higher number of bone bruises and in the presence of osteoarthritis. Resolution of individual bone bruises was prolonged in the presence of osteoarthritis and greater age. Reticular lesions were less likely to be present after 6 months than other bone bruise types."


      I'm going to be contacting Dr. Tortland shortly.

      I'll update this posting after seeing him. 

      I am wondering if others have had a similar problem.  I plan on doing a JMT in 2013 again (my 6th) but am currently planning on doing the distance I did in one day apiece for the Muir Pass and Trail Crest Pass descents into two days apiece so that I do not have such long continuous downhill descents in one day.
      Visit my Google Profile (lots of very interesting research links)

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.