Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.
 

roll over comments

Expand Messages
  • Jurydoctor@aol.com
    Jill is obviously guilty of drunk driving, but i d argue that the _primary_ fault is Jack s for grabbing the steering wheel. That would probably have caused an
    Message 1 of 1 , May 3, 2007
      Jill is obviously guilty of drunk driving, but i'd argue that the
      _primary_ fault is Jack's for grabbing the steering wheel. That would
      probably have caused an accident even if Jill had been sober.

      __________-
      As long as Jill were driving, Jack was gonna grab that wheel. But if Jill let
      Mary drive as pre arranged (is that an oral contract?) Jack wouldn't have
      touched the wheel and everyone woulda gotten home ok.
      _______________________
      First Jill (drunk driver), next the registered owner of the vehicle. If
      the R/O was in the car, Jack, Mary, Peter then they would be equal to Jill
      for knowingly allowing a drunk to drive. The only sober one Mary, should
      have NEVER gotten in the car, once the rules changed, PERIOD. She assumed
      the risk. The understanding of a designated driver, is just that, an
      understanding. Mary should have taken the keys prior to the first sip of
      alcohol being consumed. Now my question is, are they all of age to drink?
      Also, Jack should get nailed because his action caused the wreck. What's
      unknown is whether the alcohol played a factor. Jack grabbing the wheel
      of an otherwise controlled vehicle was the dangerous act.
      __________________
      They're all guilty of at least poor judgment, but Jack and Jill are
      way more at fault than the others, and Jack is guiltiest of all. Peter
      should sue the hell out of both Jack and Jill. The Jennyland Court's
      verdict is in Peter's favor and awards him whatever he asks for. We'll
      leave Mary out of it. She's just a wimp.








      ************************************** See what's free at http://www.aol.com


      [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.