Re: Massive dose vitamin A programme in India - Need for a targeted approach Indian J Med Res 138, September 2013, pp 44-50
- EDITORIALImproving child survival through vitamin A supplementationBMJ 2011; 343 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.d5294 (Published 25 August 2011)Cite this as: BMJ 2011;343:d52943 October 2013The editorial by Thorne-Lyman and Fawzi in 2011, (1) referring to the meta-analysis of the impact of vitamin A supplements by Mayo-Wilson, Imdad and others, (2,3) has now become more important than ever. The DEVTA results, only informally available in 2011, have now been published, (4) with extensive implications; indeed, as the editorial (1) says: ‘… the null findings have left lingering questions. Is vitamin A supplementation effective?’. These results have been the subject of conflicting comments recently in the Lancet, e.g. (5,6). But a number of inferences that should be drawn from the compilation and analysis of the evidence from trials prior to DEVTA (2,3) help answer this lingering question, and have not received adequate attention. There are three key related points, which now point to the need to seriously consider concrete steps to move beyond 6-monthly vitamin A supplementation at unphysiological levels.First, the trend through time in reported impact on mortality of high dose vitamin A 6-monthly supplements (usually 200,000 IUs) is informative, but some important inferences are not being drawn. The original meta-analyses by Beaton et al (7) in 1993 drew upon the 8 studies available at that time, to estimate an average mortality reduction (in 12-59 month children) of 23%. The recent meta-analyses (2,3) drew on seven of these, and added a further nine. They concluded that the weighted average mortality finding (without DEVTA) was essentially unchanged. What they did not point out is that 89% of the weight in this average came from the seven pre 1993 trials; the remaining 9 trials, with 11% weight, not surprisingly had little effect on the calculation.Further, it was not pointed out that of the 16 results, 8 showed no significant impact; since 1993, only two of 9 showed impact. Thus what is being confirmed is that the early trials showed efficacy; but there is sparse evidence in the past 20 years for this still being so, and none for large scale effectiveness. It seems disingenuous to imply that these new analyses confirm the continuing efficacy of VAC supplements.Second, by not including the possibility of changing impact through time, the effect of major changes in disease patterns is ignored. The impact on mortality was estimated in the original trials as resulting from reducing deaths from measles and diarrhea; no other causes were significant. (7, p50) Measles has been greatly reduced, by successful immunization programs, since the 1990’s; and diarrhea deaths have fallen, with improved living conditions, use of health services, and of ORT.Although the mechanism for intermittent high-dose VACs to reduce mortality is not known, it is only established as being relevant in these two diseases (7). Thus it is to be expected that mortality impact, if still present, would be reduced. The negative results of DEVTA, and of the study referred to by Benn et al, (8) are thus also not surprising. Both of these investigations, refuting conventional wisdom, suffered extraordinarily long delays in publication, in the DEVTA case causing speculation that ‘undoubtedly, the fact that there was no apparent effect detected delayed publication’. (5) Benn et al have a similar view about their unpublished results.(8) It is also seems disingenuous to assert that VACs are ‘a proven life-saving intervention’, (9) as if this necessarily continues under changing conditions, and in countries where measles has been controlled and diarrhea prevention and treatment improved.Third, vitamin A deficiency (VAD) is measured by serum retinol, as recommended by WHO. (10) The prevalence of VAD is around 30% in poor countries and falling only slowly.(11) However, it is clear that 6-monthly high dose VAD has only a limited and transient impact on serum retinol, (12, refs 6-20) which is how vitamin A gets to target tissues. There are established effective methods for reducing VAD: frequent physiological intakes of vitamin A or precursors through improved diets, fortification, and/or low dose supplements; (12, refs 22-35) moreover this is considered safe in pregnancy, in contrast to VACs.So the question becomes: why has most of the attention been on VACs (13) (over 7 billion so far distributed), (14) of unproven effectiveness in operational programmes, when employing these other approaches would have a wider range of benefits, including addressing any residual impact on child mortality that VACs 6-monthly may be having?This would free up scarce resources now being used for VAC campaigns, which have considerable opportunity costs.(15) Improved diets, fortified foods, and multiple micronutrient provision would surely bring broader improvements in nutrition to more people, including reproductive aged women who are now largely excluded.John Mason, PhD, David Sanders MD, Roger Shrimpton PhD, Ted Greiner PhD.1) School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Tulane University, New Orleans
2) School of Public Health, University of the Western Cape, South Africa
3) Department of Nutrition, Hanyang University, South Korea.1 Thorne-Lyman A, Fawzi WW. Improving child survival through vitamin A supplementation. BMJ. 2011 Aug 25;343:d5294. doi: 10.1136/bmj.d5294. PubMed PMID: 21868480
2 Mayo-Wilson E, Imdad A, Herzer K, Yakoob MY, Bhutta ZA. Vitamin A supplements for preventing mortality, illness, and blindness in children aged under 5: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2011 Aug 25;343:d5094. doi: 10.1136/bmj.d5094. Review. PubMed PMID: 21868478; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3162042
3 Imdad A, Herzer K, Mayo-Wilson E, Yakoob MY, Bhutta ZA. Vitamin A supplementation for preventing morbidity and mortality in children from 6 months to 5 years of age.Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Dec 8;(12):CD008524. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008524.pub2. Review. PubMed PMID: 21154399
4 Awasthi S, Peto R, Read S, Richards SM, Pande V, Bundy D; DEVTA (Deworming and Enhanced Vitamin A) team. Population deworming every 6 months with albendazole in 1 million pre-school children in north India: DEVTA, a cluster-randomised trial.Lancet. 2013 Apr 27;381(9876):1478-86. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(12)62126-6. Epub 2013 Mar 14. PubMed PMID: 23498850; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3647147.
5 Garner P, Taylor-Robinson D, Sachdev HS. DEVTA: results from the biggest clinical trial ever. Lancet. 2013 Apr 27;381(9876):1439-41. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60600-5. Epub 2013 Mar 14. PubMed PMID: 23498851
6 Sommer A, West KP Jr, Martorell R. Vitamin A supplementation in Indian children.Lancet. 2013 Aug 17;382(9892):591. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60645-5. Epub 2013 Mar 22. PubMed PMID: 23528188
7 Beaton, G., Martorell, R., Aronson, K., Edmonston, B., McCabe, G., Ross, A. & Harvey, B. (1993) Effectiveness of Vitamin A Supplementation in the Control of Young Child Morbidity and Mortality in Developing Countries. ACC/SCN State-of-the-Art Series, Nutrition Policy Discussion Paper No. 13. ACC/SCN, Geneva.http://www.unscn.org/layout/modules/resources/files/Policy_paper_No_13.pdf
8 Benn CS, Fisker AB, Aaby P. Vitamin A supplementation in Indian children. Lancet. 2013 Aug 17;382(9892):593. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)61737-7. PubMed PMID: 23953380
9 Mannar V, Schultink W, Spahn K. Vitamin A supplementation in Indian children.Lancet. 2013 Aug 17;382(9892):591-2. PubMed PMID: 23961552.
10 Sommer A, Davidson FR; Annecy Accords. Assessment and control of vitamin A deficiency: the Annecy Accords. J Nutr. 2002 Sep;132(9 Suppl):2845S-2850S. PubMed PMID: 12221259
11 UN Standing Committee on Nutrition. Progress in Nutrition. 6th Report on the World Nutrition Situation. UN-SCN, Geneva. 2010.http://www.unscn.org/files/Publications/RWNS6/html/index.html
12 Mason JB, Ramirez MA, Fernandez CM, Pedro R, Lloren T, Saldanha L, Deitchler M, Eisele T. Effects on vitamin A deficiency in children of periodic high-dose supplements and of fortified oil promotion in a deficient area of the Philippines. Int J Vitam Nutr Res. 2011 Sep;81(5):295-305. doi: 10.1024/0300-9831/a000077. PubMed PMID: 22419200
13 UNICEF. Vitamin A Supplementation: a Decade of Progress. 2007, New York.
14 Micronutrient Initiative. 20 Years of Progress. 2011/12 Annual Report. Ottawa.
15 Doherty T, Chopra M, Tomlinson M, Oliphant N, Nsibande D, Mason J. Moving from vertical to integrated child health programmes: experiences from a multi-country assessment of the Child Health Days approach in Africa. Trop Med Int Health. 2010 Mar;15(3):296-305.Competing interests: None declaredJohn B Mason, ProfessorDavid Sanders, Roger Shrimpton, Ted GreinerTulane University School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, 1440 Canal Street, Ste 2300, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA Orleans· Help© 2013 BMJ Publishing Group LtdDr. Umesh KapilProfessor Public Health Nutrition
Room Number 118;Human Nutrition Unit,
Old OT Block,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences
New Delhi, India ,110029
On Sunday, September 15, 2013 8:04 PM, Prof. Umesh Kapil <umeshkapil@...> wrote:
Indian J Med Res 138, September 2013, pp 44-50Massive dose vitamin A programme in India - Need for a targeted approachUmesh Kapil & H.P.S. Sachdev*All India Institute of Medical Sciences & *Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science & Research, New Delhi, IndiaReceived February 1, 2012The National Prophylaxis Programme against Nutritional Blindness due to vitamin A deficiency (NPPNB due to VAD) was started in 1970 with the specific aim of preventing nutritional blindness due to keratomalacia . The Programme was launched as an urgent remedial measure to combat the unacceptably high magnitude of xerophthalmic blindness in the country seen in the 1950s and 1960s. Clinical VAD has declined drastically during the last 40 years. Also, indicators of child health have shown substantial gains in different States in the country. The prevalence of severe undernutrition has come down significantly. Immunization coverage for measles and other vaccine preventable diseases has improved from 5-7 per cent in early seventies to currently 60-90 per cent, in different States. Similarly, there has been a significant improvement in the overall dietary intake of young children. There has been virtual disappearance of keratomalacia, and a sharp decline in the prevalence of Bitot spots. Prophylactic mega dose administration of vitamin A is primarily advocated because of the claim of 23 per cent reduction in childhood mortality. However, benefits on this scale have been found only in areas with rudimentary health care facilities where clinical deficiency is common, and there is substantial heterogeneity, especially with inclusion of all trials. There is an urgent need for adopting a targeted rather than universal prophylactic mega dose vitamin A supplementation in preschool children. This approach is justified on the basis of currently available evidence documenting a substantial decline in VAD prevalence, substantial heterogeneity and uncertainty about mortality effects in present era with improved health care, and resource constraints with competing priorities.Dr. Umesh KapilProfessor Public Health Nutrition
Room Number 118;Human Nutrition Unit,
Old OT Block,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences
New Delhi, India ,110029
From: Anant Bhan <dranantbhan@...>
To: IAPSM youth group <email@example.com>
Cc: Comm Med Karnataka e-group <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Thursday, April 22, 2010 10:43 PM
Subject: [iapsm_youthmembers] MCI CHIEF HELD FOR SEEKING BRIBE
http://timesofindia .indiatimes. com/India/ MCI-boss- Ketan-Desai- arrested/ articleshow/ 5847065.cms
Also see related earlier write ups from the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics.
http://www.ijme. in/173AR125. html
http://ijme. in/182le124. html