Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.
 

Thomas and Marcion

Expand Messages
  • Tom Saunders
    Using Throckmorton, I have compared the parallels of Thomas to Luke, Matthew, Mark, and Marcion. I find no matches from NT works to Marcion and Thomas in
    Message 1 of 1 , Jun 6, 2002
      Using Throckmorton, I have compared the parallels of Thomas to Luke, Matthew, Mark, and Marcion. I find no matches from NT works to Marcion and Thomas in sayings 24, 26, 33, 34, 35, 45, 61, 64, 66, 73, 89, 94, and 97. Please feel free to correct of supplement the list below.

      Thomas Logion no. 1

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other See Thomas 18 and 19

      Thomas Logion no. 2

      Matt: 7-7, 11-29

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 3

      Matt:

      Luke: 17-21

      Marcion: The Kingdom of God is Within You 20,21

      Other

      Note: see also 113 of Thomas to compare with Marcion

      Thomas Logion no. 4

      Matt: 11-25

      Luke: 10-21

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 5

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-2

      Marcion: Parable of the Lamp 17, Leaven of the Pharisees 2

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 6

      Matt: 10-26

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 7

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 8

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 9

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 10

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-49

      Marcion: Fire On Earth 49 to 51

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 11

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Beware of Scribes 32, 33

      Other

      Note: Marcion and Thomas differ as to make these sayings only similar

      Thomas Logion no. 12

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 13

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 14

      Matt: 15-11

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 15

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 16

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-51,52

      Marcion: Fire On Earth 50 to 53

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 17

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 18

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 19

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 20

      Matt: 13-31,32

      Luke:

      Marcion: Mustard Seed

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 21

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 22

      Matt: 19-12

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 23

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 24

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Leaven of the Pharisees 3

      Other

      Note: This Marcion reference appears to be a cross between sayings 24 and 33.

      Thomas Logion no. 25

      Matt: 22-39

      Luke: 10-27

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 26

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: New Edicts for a New God 42

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 27

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other: Mark 2-19,20 2-27,28

      Thomas Logion no. 28

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 29

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 30

      Matt: 18-20

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 31

      Matt: 13-57

      Luke: 4-24

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 32

      Matt: 5-14

      Luke:

      Marcion: Good Fruit, Evil Fruit 48

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 33

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Parable of the Lamp 17, also Lamp of the body 33

      Other

      Note Marcion 17 only similar to Thomas

      Thomas Logion no. 34

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: New Edicts for a New God 39

      Other

      Note: Similar sayings exist concerning the blind, Throckmorton has not listed.

      Thomas Logion no. 35

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: A House Divided 21

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 36

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 37

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 38

      Matt:

      Luke: 10-24

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 39

      Matt: 10-16, 23-13

      Luke: 11-52

      Marcion: Woe 52

      Other

      Note Marcion uses lawyers in place of scribes.

      Thomas Logion no. 40

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 41

      Matt: 13-12, 25-29

      Luke: 19-26

      Marcion: Parable of the Lamp 18,19. A Certain Nobleman 26

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 42

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 43

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 44

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-10

      Marcion: Leaven of the Pharisees 10

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 45

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Good Fruit, Evil Fruit 43,44,45

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 46

      Matt: 11-11

      Luke: 7-28

      Marcion: John the Baptist 48

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 47

      Matt:

      Luke: 5-39

      Marcion: Old aand New 36,37,38

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 48

      Matt: 12-21

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 49

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 50

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 51

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 52

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no.53

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 54

      Matt: 5-3

      Luke: 6-20

      Marcion: New Edicts of the New God 20

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 55

      Matt: 10-37,38

      Luke: 15-26,27

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 56

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 57

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 58

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 59

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 60

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 61

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Two will rest in Bed....

      Other

      Note: Marcion only has similarity to Thomas.

      Thomas Logion no. 62

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 63

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-16,21

      Marcion: Who Appointed Me Judge 16 to 21

      Other

      Thomas Logion no.64

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Guest Parable 16 to 24

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 65

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 66

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Good Fruit, Evil Fruit 48,49

      Other

      Note: There is only a similarity to Marcion here

      Thomas Logion no. 67

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 68

      Matt: 5-11

      Luke: 6-22

      Marcion: New Edicts of a New God 22

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 69

      Matt: 5-10, 5-6

      Luke: 6-21

      Marcion: New Edicts for a New God 21

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 70

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 71

      Matt: 26-61

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other: Mark 14-58

      Thomas Logion no. 72

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-13,14

      Marcion: Who Apointed me Judge 13,14,15

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 73

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: New Disciples 2

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 74

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 75

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 76

      Matt: 6-19,21 13-45,46

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 77

      Matt: 18-20

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 78

      Matt: 11-8

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 79

      Matt:

      Luke: 11-27,28

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 80

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 81

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 82

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 83

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 84

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 85

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 86

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 87

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 88

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 89

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Woe 39-40

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 90

      Matt: 11-28,30

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 91

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 92

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 93

      Matt: 7-6

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 94

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Prayer for the Holy Spirit 10

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 95

      Matt: 5-42

      Luke: 6-30

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 96

      Matt:

      Luke: 13-20

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 97

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion: Leaven bread

      Other

      Note: Only a similarity exits here between Thomas and Marcion, see 96 also

      Thomas Logion no. 98

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 99

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 100

      Matt: 22-17ff

      Luke:

      Marcion: Tribute to Caesar 22 to 26

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 101

      Matt: 10-37, 38

      Luke: 14-26,27

      Marcion: Discipleship 26,27

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 102

      Matt: 23-13

      Luke: 11-52

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 103

      Matt:

      Luke: 12-39

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 104

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other: Mark 11-20

      Thomas Logion no. 105

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 106

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 107

      Matt: 18-12,13

      Luke: 15-37

      Marcion: Joy in the Presence of God 3 to 7

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 108

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 109

      Matt: 13-14

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 110

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 111

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 112

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other

      Thomas Logion no. 113

      Matt: 24-23

      Luke: 17-21

      Marcion: The Kingdom of God is Within You 20, 21

      Other

      Note: See also No. 3

      Thomas Logion no. 114

      Matt:

      Luke:

      Marcion:

      Other



      [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.