Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Vandalic name for Goths

Expand Messages
  • Ryszard Derdzinski
    Heils! After a long period of silence I would like to relate what I have found in a very interesting Polish book entitled Najstarsza warstwa nazewnicza na
    Message 1 of 1 , Aug 21, 2002

      After a long period of silence I would like to relate what I have found in a
      very interesting Polish book entitled "Najstarsza warstwa nazewnicza na
      ziemiach polskich" ('The Oldest Onomastic Layer In The Territory of Poland')
      by Zbigniew Babik, Cracow 2001.

      The author points out a big group of place-names (including river- and
      lake-names) belonging to the so called Layer I (or pre-Slavic, before
      5th/6th c.) and among them a group of Germanic names (I will write about
      them in the next message). One of them is _Trlag_ (_a_ being here nasal _o_:
      something like 'trlong') - a lake in Polish region Kujawy (Cuiavia) and a
      nearby village. Babik (after Vasmer's "Germanen und Slaven in Ostdeutschland
      in alter Zeit", 1933) reconstructs it as Germanic _*Tru(l)ling-_
      'Troll-lake_. Though Vasmer refered it to the Scandinavian/Viking influence
      of early Middle Ages, Babik cannot agree with this interpretation. According
      to him the Viking settlement in early Middle Ages in the area of Trlag is
      much more improbable than Gothic settlement in the late antiquity (as
      described in Jordanes' "Gethica").

      The Scandinavian name _troll_ can be reconstructed in Germanic as _*trula-_
      or _*trulla-_ (see Torp's "Der Wortschatz der Germanischen Spracheinheit",
      Goettingen 1909). A very interesting citation from Babik's book is:

      "Vasmer (in "Ein vandalischer Name der Goten", Studia Neophilologica XV,
      Uppsala 1942) writes also about the name given by the Vandals to the Goths
      settled in Spain (Greek _trouloun_), which he interprets as contemptuous
      surname 'trolls'" (Babik 2001, p. 282).

      What do you think about all this? If this interpretation of place-name
      _Trlag_, the Germanic _*trul(l)a-_ and Greek _trouloun_ is right we know a
      little more about the mythology of Goths and Vandals (they believed in
      trolls) and we can add a new word to the limited Vandalic glossary.

      P.S. Another troll-name in today Poland is _Trloga_ (river and village near
      Przasnysz in north-east Poland) which is reconstructed by Babik as
      _*Tru(l)lag-_ '[river, marsh] of the troll(s)' (_*-ag-_ is a relational
      element in Germanic).


      (Ryszard Derdzinski)

      maggot@... or galadhorn@...

      "Gwaith-i-Phethdain" http://www.elvish.org/gwaith
      "Polish Tolkien Society" http://www.parmadili.w.pl
      "Silesian Homeland" http://necik.mag.com.pl/~galadhorn/slask/index.htm
      "Sindarin Dictionary": http://www.uib.no/People/hnohf/gobeth.htm
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.