Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

12487Re: some questions

Expand Messages
  • lady_caritas
    Jun 14, 2006
      --- In gnosticism2@yahoogroups.com, GP <swtmeadow@...> wrote:
      > Hello,
      > I'm not really new to Gnosticism. But I am struggling lately with
      some more or less obvious problems that I'm sure others of you have
      >run into. I am wondering how you dealt with them.

      Hello, GP. I've been thinking about your questions, and I'll just
      offer a few ideas to kick around or throw out, whatever you decide.
      These are purely personal reflections of mine.

      > First, I realize that unlike Sophia, I don't know where I belong
      but I'm pretty sure it isn't "here." So, how do you find out where
      you belong? Do you wait until grace is offered from another plane
      much as Christ offered grace to Sophia because she prayed so
      > Second, it has occurred to me that perhaps this IS where I belong
      despite my dissatisfaction with where I am. I long for something more
      free -- less burdened by the heaviness of the physical, but is that
      really an indication that I belong somewhere else? Perhaps I could be
      of the world but not in it (as some religious groups advise) and
      simply be of service to what seems best in this Malcut of a place
      (sorry for the place name dropping!)<<

      Or you could be in this world but not of it... The Gnostics did
      recognize the material world as real, even if corruptible. And
      that's where we all function right now. As far as "another
      plane,"... do you like to obediently "wait," GP? Does prayer have
      meaning for you? IOW, you need to be honest with yourself and
      continue to learn to know yourself.

      Saying 3 from The Gospel of Thomas says, "If those who lead you
      (plur.) say to you, `See, the kingdom is in heaven,' then the birds
      of heaven will precede you. If they say to you, `It is the sea,'
      then the fish will precede you. But the kingdom is inside you of
      you. And it is outside of you."

      Also, from Saying 6, "His disciples questioned him and said to
      him, `Do you want us to fast? And how shall we pray? Shall we give
      alms? And what kind of diet shall we follow?' Jesus said, `Do not
      lie, and do not do what you hate. For all things are disclosed
      before heaven. For there is nothing obscure that will not be shown
      forth, and there is nothing covered that will remain without being

      > Finally, I ain't no intellectual. Most of what I know is
      um....empirical or has been taught me orally or by demonstration. How
      important is book learning to the pursuit of understanding ourselves?
      (I can't think how to phrase this without it sounding
      um....smartalecy.....not meant in that way!) I read lots but retain
      little from books. Thanks for your responses.
      > GP

      GP, I'm thinking it might not be about being "intellectual" so much
      as that we all have different learning styles. If you're retaining
      little from reading books, have you considered making audiotapes of
      selected writings and listening to them? No matter how you "read"
      them, have you taken that empirical knowledge and those oral
      teachings you speak of and knocked them around against ideas from the
      ancient Gnostics or modern authors who talk about them? I find that
      getting involved and critically comparing to my own experience helps
      make the reading meaningful. And there are also times when I'm just
      swept up by the poetry of it all.

      In any case, our group is always available to discuss these readings
      if that is of any help to you. Maybe other members have further
      helpful ideas or suggestions.

    • Show all 27 messages in this topic