Re: [FH] Weight loss (was CoQ-10 and L-Carnitine dosages)
- Hi Gwen,
In a message dated 10/31/05 9:57:10 PM, paragem@... writes:
<< My Bud is 16 lbs >>
What does Bud eat (brand, flavor, canned or dry)? The leading contributing
factor to obesity in cats is a dry food diet, which is high in carbohydrate.
Just two excerpts from the links below:
1. From Elizabeth Hodgkins DVM (former director of Hill's Pet Nutrition) at
"Excessive carbohydrate consumption, over time, causes both obesity and
strongly predisposes the cat, an obligatory carnivore, to the metabolic "train
wreak" we know as type II feline diabetes mellitus....Consumption of dry cat food
causes a very rapid and extreme surge in blood glucose as the predigested
carbohydrate in the food is dissolved and absorbed into the bloodstream
essentially as sugar from the stomach and intestines....Along the way, the constant high
insulin levels (hyperinsulinemia) cause the cat to experience
hypertriglyceridemia (high triglycerides) and hypercholesterolemia (high cholesterol), and
obesity results....For now, there is compelling scientific evidence to show that
high carbohydrate diets (essentially all dry cat foods) fed to pet cats on a
continuous and exclusive basis predispose to, or even directly cause, feline
obesity and type II feline diabetes mellitus."
2. From Lisa A. Pierson, DVM at www.catinfo.org:
"Obesity is an extremely common and very serious health problem in cats. For
instance, overweight cats are four times more likely to develop diabetes than
cats that are at an optimal weight. Obligate carnivores are designed to meet
their energy needs with a high protein, moderate fat diet with little to no
carbohydrates. Carbohydrates are minimally used for energy and those that are
not used are converted to and stored as fat. The so-called “light” diets that
are on the market have targeted the fat content as the nutrient to be
decreased, but in doing so, the pet food manufacturers have increased the grain
fraction, leading to a higher level of carbohydrates. Hence, many overweight cats
eating these diets are still obese. These "light" products are among the most
species-inappropriate, unhealthy diets available to cat caretakers. Many
caretakers feed very small amounts of these diets hoping that their cat will lose
weight but feeding a small amount of a diet that is inappropriate for the species
is NOT the answer!".
<< the vet says that is TOO MUCH - in fact, he
is what she calls "pre-diabetic". >>
See above. A high carbohydrate diet is also the leading contributing factor
to feline diabetes. Cats who are borderline...with a blood glucose of 150-200
mg/dL...are giving us a warning that the pancreas is starting to not function.
Changing the diet to a high-quality, low-carbohdyrate, well-balanced,
moisture-rich, meat-based diet...that is, the diet for which a cat's body was
designed...can restore pancreatic function in most cats.
<< the bad news was the
high sugar. >>
How high? Above 200 mg/dL? Was it a fasting blood sample? If not, how many
hrs was the sample taken after a meal?
<< She says she has seen cats lose weight and stay on one of the
prescription diets and get rid of the diabetes >>
She may have seen that. But there is absolutely no reason to feed any cat a
"prescription" diet, which are uniformly of poor nutritional quality. This is
doubly true for diabetics, who used to be prescribed Hill's w/d...which is a
high-carbohydrate, high-fiber diet that is completely contraindicated for cats,
esp diabetics (it doesn't work well in humans or dogs, either)...precisely b/c
it is high in carbohydrate. Now they are prescribed either Purina DM or
Hill's m/d, both of which may have lower carbohdyrate content than most commercial
dry foods (13% of calories, as opposed to the usual 20-50%; Innova's new EVO
has 7% of calories from carbohdyrate)...but they have very poor nutritional
There are several canned commercial products with high nutritional quality
and low carbohydrates. These incl: Wellness, www.oldmotherhubbard.com; Nature's
Variety, www.naturesvariety.com; PetGuard, www.petguard.com; Felidae,
www.canidae.com; Natural Balance, www.naturalbalanceinc.com; Innova,
www.naturapet.com; and Eagle Pack, www.eaglepack.com.
Only the first 2 are grain free in the entire line...and contain usually less
than 5% calories from carbohydrate. The rest contain grains but are generally
<< I need to find a good way
to help him lose a couple of pounds. >>
Cats will achieve and stabilize at a healthy weight for their frames when fed
a species-appropriate diet.
<< Any suggestions will be appreciated. >>
It might be useful to start with feline nutrition. Many of these articles
also contain information about the relationship between diet and
diabetes/obesity. Feeding the high-quality species-appropriate diet that cats need "magically"
eliminates many common health problems.
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, savionna@a... wrote:
But there is absolutely no reason to feed any cat a "prescription"
diet, which are uniformly of poor nutritional quality. This is
doubly true for diabetics...
As usual, I agree with Rosemary. With minimal understanding of
feline nutritional requirements and an understanding of what needs
to be tweaked with certain conditions, you can often do better on
your own. If you have the time and willingness to do this.
If not, there IS a line of prescription diets that seems to be based
on science rather than profits: Wysong. I have no financial
connection and will probably always make my own. While not still
perfect, IMO, for those most comfortable with a prescription diet,
it's an option that you should have your vets investigate.
Dr Wysong's "Scientific & Philosophical basis of Rx Diets" paper
does an excellent job at explaining nutritional concepts which few
vets unfortunately don't understand.
Feeding food that the cat's body is able & designed to utilize is
the best defense against disease. When cats are fighting other
illnesses, it's even more important. Many of the supplements
recommended for heart kitties, I was able to get into Mr Pepe in
their original form, aka food.
Check out the "Pancreas Size" chart on pg 14. Rats & Mice fed
processed foods have pancreas's that are more than twice the size
(.84 vs .32) as those fed a species appropriate diet. The pancreas
is one of the masters of our immune system and allows us fight
disease. Bigger is not better, since this indicates its working too
hard and is breaking down.
I had a funny dog experience a few weeks ago, which hammered this
home. I took my 4.5 yr old dog in for an ultrasound to check her
reproductive organs. The first thing out of the vets mouth
was "whoa, what a pancreas!" His assistant walks in and he shouts
to her, "check out Buddie's pancreas?" I was afraid to ask what's
wrong with her pancreas - thinking the worse. As dogs age, it
becomes bigger, mushier and less distinct on u/s. Her's jumped off
the screen and looked like a puppy's pancreas. I took her off
kibble at 7 mos and have been feeding her a species appropriate diet
for the past 4 years. Looks like her pancreas hasn't aged since the
Lisa: It was Dr C who got so excited about Buddie's pancreas. He's
also one of the few vets in the area who doesn't hassle raw
feeders. I hope he made the connection.