Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

338Re: More tengwar in PE19 (in OP2)

Expand Messages
  • Mans
    Jan 2 11:17 PM
      --- In elfscript2@yahoogroups.com, j_mach_wust@... wrote:
      >
      > On 2012-01-01, at 17:54, Ugo wrote:
      >
      > > Hello everyone,
      > > I haven't found any mention here, but there are more tengwar in PE19 than those already highlighted in #329, all from OP2.
      >
      > Thanks for pointing that out! Indeed, this raises an intricate question: How should we count these? They are not tengwar autographs, seeing as they are only reproduced in Tengwar Annatar characters. Still, they come directly from Tolkien's manuscript.

      That is enough to include them: the index is meant to reference the source documents, not published editions. Indeed, a text does not even have to be published - just knowing its existence is reason to index it, as in the case of DTS 82.

      Yours,
      MÃ¥ns
    • Show all 5 messages in this topic