Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Re: My poem is now completely transcribed

Expand Messages
  • j_mach_wust
    ... No it isn t. There s e.g. the so-called original mode (also by Chris in the very same Tengwar Textbook). Or there s a very short yet still complete
    Message 1 of 6 , Oct 31, 2004
      Gregson Vaux wrote:
      > What I think Chris McKay has done is to attempt to make this
      > tutorial and to be as true to JRRT as possible while still having
      > something workable. I very much believe that we need a uniform
      > English mode and as far as I know, Chris McKay's is the only one out
      > there.

      No it isn't. There's e.g. the so-called 'original mode' (also by Chris
      in the very same Tengwar Textbook). Or there's a very short yet still
      complete description of a Tolkienian full mode by Danny Andriƫs:


      I've tried to make a similar description of a Tolkienian tehtar mode
      (but I'd recommend you also have a look at the following discussion):


      If you only want to know the differences between your use of Chris
      McKay's "Common Mode" and Tolkien's use, then I'd suggest you reread
      the messages #4265 and #4278 not as an endless back reference to
      inconsistent fragments, but as precise information on how the spelling
      should be according to Tolkien's example (because that was what I
      intended them to be).

      > I guess I wasn't very clear. I very much believe in correctness but
      > in the case of an English mode, what is correct? I am making the
      > case that the Tengwar textbook is correct and I especially respect
      > that it is a tutorial that helps the new learner. I see all of these
      > arguments about what is correct but it seems that Tolkien did not
      > leave a large enough body of consistent writing to properly judge
      > what is correct.

      The body is very narrow (only about half a dozen of samples). However,
      it's large and consistent enough to build a useful mode on it. Only
      very few guesses remain to be made (notably a consistent
      representation of _ee_ and _oo_). There's no need at all to rely on
      secondary samples not made by J. R. R. Tolkien himself.

      j. 'mach' wust
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.