90The Book of Mazarbul (Re: [elfscript] The runes of The Hobbit.)
- Nov 6, 2000Greetings,
On Fri, 3 Nov 2000 Arden R. Smith wrote:
> Tolkien later used a subscript line for the same purpose in the cirth of
> the Book of Mazarbul (_Pictures_ #23, page III). I'm not aware of such a
> use of diacritical marks to indicate gemination in any historical runic
> inscriptions. [...]
That's the reason which triggered my post: Dwarves used a variant
of Anglo-Saxon runes, but that under-dot seemed "alien". That's all. From
this point I tried to "extend" the use of that dot to get a more regular
behaviour (ok, I know, ancient inscriptions aren't very regular :-)).
Now that you've mentioned the Book of Mazarbul: those two pages
written with the cirth, in the so called "Erebor mode" (as far as I know),
reproduced English text and, with a bit of patience, I've re-translated
them and mapped almost each certh to its roman value.
Here comes a little problem: according to Appendix E of LoR the
Erebor mode has some unique features and some changes, but not everything
is shown in the cirth table. When I first read LoR many years ago I
thought having understood those sentences about Erebor mode quite well,
but those pages of the Book throw in some confusion: some cirth have
"unexpected" values (please, note that I'm not referring here to the
"extra" cirth or the under-bar).
Being that it's used to write English I think some cirth could
have "special" values better suited for the English language; do you think
that in the Middle-earth context this mode used in the Book of Mazarbul's
pages could be the real "Erebor mode"?
> [...] In later impressions (and in the first impression of _The Return
> of the King_), this has been corrected by changing the final #55
> (schwa) into #9 (d) and squeezing a stemless #56 between the _t_ and
> the _d_. See Wayne Hammond's _J. R. R. Tolkien: A Descriptive
> Bibliography_, p. 94, for facsimiles of the original and corrected
Thanks for the reference, I'll look for the book.
"He loved maps, as I have told you before; and he also
liked runes and letters and cunning handwriting..."
-- J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>