6712Re: Censureship at Eckankar Survivors Anonymous?
- Jul 3, 2007Not so fast, Liz. I've checked into my Yahoo groups account, which
lists the groups I am a member of on Yahoo. The two other ex-eckankar
groups are still there, but the ESA group has been deleted.
This, of course, was done by Prometheus when he deleted my
membership. I'd thought moderated status was different than complete
deletion of membership.
In any case, I have NO membership with ESA to edit, so there are
obviously no membership choices for me to select or deselect.
So, since my usual email address was banned by him, Yahoo groups
apparently automatically reverted to my alternate email address which
is still stored in yahoo groups. It seems to be a quirk in yahoo
group programming. There is no way for me to change that other than
re-establishing membership in ESA (sorry, no thanks), or deleting
from my general yahoo account the alternate address, which I may do.
Prometheus has as much stated the same thing over at ESA. I accept
this explanation, and that it was not deliberate on the part of
Prometheus. Of course, Prometheus' act of completely banning/deleting
the email address set these events in motion, but I can see that he
could not have known this would happen. When I last I to ESA, I did
not notice the automatic reversion back to the other email address.
Fair enough for you, Liz?
On this forum, I am so far NOT banned. So here, when you make a
statement, you get an answer.
On your group, you have control of the bully pulpit, so you can make
any statement you want with inpunity.
No one will answer you if you decide you don't like the answer.
This is called censureship when you have complete control of what
gets posted, and can decide how you want to manipulate the
So I won't be posting on your group. You've become tyrannical in your
style of managing the group.
Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "Elizabeth" <ewickings@...>
> FYI, if a person is really all that concerned about whether a
> moderator edited or switched a poster's email or address once it
> approved, all one has to do is look at the post in question, to theyou
> right and below the date it will say: "Show message option". If
> click the tiny arrow it will expand the area to show: "Viewone
> Source", "Use Fixed Width Font", or "Unwrap Lines". Click the
> that says "Show message". It will then open up the post at theleft
> of the page, and before the actual message it will show who it isto
> from, return path, Received.... Etc which for most people is hard
> read let alone understand if you have no clue what you are lookingif
> for. Down toward the bottom of all that strange stuff you will see
> From, Subject, X-Yahoo-Group-Post: public or it might say member,
> it says public, it means the person sending a post is not a memberof
> the group. The last line will show: X-eGroups-Approved-By: eitherwas
> Prometheus or myself over on ESA. It will also show if anything
> edited, and by which moderator. This pertains to the messageposted
> on ESA Re: Group FYIthen
> If this explaination is too difficult for anyone to understand,
> I guess the point is not worth explaining further... This is nottoo
> difficult to prove to yourselves. It is impossible to remove ora
> change a person's message without it showing this within the "Show
> Message Option" as I referrenced. Of course one way to accomplish
> doing any editing and posting, would be to forward one of these
> moderated posts from the original message, and post it yourself as
> moderator. Which in this case in question, was not how it happenedhere:
> on ESA!
> Hope everyone has an enjoyable July 4th Holiday week/end.
> Leaf wrote:
> --- In email@example.com, "tomleafeater" <tianyue@>
> > Well, for what its worth...here's another update, and some
> > thoughts for Marla, if she's reading this.
> > I logged into my Yahoo groups account, and I see that with all my
> > yahoo groups that I hold memberships with, ESA has been
> > changed to my alternate email address that is stored in my
> > Yahoo file. The other two groups still have my usual email
> > address.
> > Now, I did NOT change this. That is a cold, hard fact. I haven't
> > logged into Yahoo accounts in ages.
> > I figure that when I was placed on moderated status by the
> > moderators at ESA, they somehow switched me to the alternate
> > email address that is on file in my account.
> > This may have been deliberate or not. I can't say.
> > So now, unless this is changed, I am forced to use an email
> > address I'd rather not use, if I ever post there.
> > This is getting stranger by the day.
> > Well, I just have to laugh....not at anyone or with malice, just
> > laugh....
> > I'm okay with all this, at peace with myself.
> > Its been one crazy and wild adventure!
> > I may post a wrap-up of all this, and some final thoughts, when I
> > have time. Then I may retreat back into my peronsal life,
> > although I'll probably check back in once in a while.
> > For now, I'd like to say to Marla one thing, if she's reading
> > I left eckankar about ten years ago, after joining when I was
> > about sixteen years old, and have been reading the eckankar
> > sites for quite some time, off and on. I've seen some strange
> > and wacky things come and go that have been posted.
> > There was nothing at all controversial with your posts, nothing
> > even slightly unusual or inappropriate compared to what has
> > always been posted over the years on these forums.
> > In fact, your posts, I'd say, were fairly usual and normal. This
> > why it is so puzzling that you were singled out for such a tonguethe
> > lashing. It makes no sense to me, with all that I've seen over
> > years.were
> > I'm sorry (oops, not supposed to say 'sorry' in eckankar, I just
> > can't seem to follow the little rules anymore--hee, hee) you
> > put through such an ordeal in your contact with theseto
> > ex-eckankar groups. You deserved to be respected and to be
> > treated with dignity. That didn't happen. You seem like a very
> > good, decent and smart person to me. You've handled it all with
> > poise.
> > You'll be fine, I'm sure.
> > Although I'm not the moderator here, I think its safe to say you
> > should feel free to post at this forum, if you liike. There have
> > a great many decent and good people post here over the years.
> > You're welcome here, although I wouldn't blame you if you leave
> > any thought of eckankar behind and never look back.
> > Funny, that's what these forums were supposed to be all about.
> > More later.
> > Leaf
> > --- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "tomleafeater"
> > <tianyue@> wrote:
> > >
> > > There is only one way that my email address that Yahoo
> > groups uses
> > > can be changed: I have to physically log into Yahoo groups with
> > my
> > > password and deliberately elect to change to another email
> > address. I
> > > always post at the Yahoo site, not from my email program.
> > >
> > > The name change only took effect on YOUR site, and not here
> > on
> > > Eckankartruth, which is also a Yahoo group. If I'd made a
> > change, the
> > > new address would have shown up here, as well. As anyone
> > can see, it
> > > didn't.
> > >
> > > Let's see with this new post how my name shows up. If my real
> > name is
> > > displayed, I apologize in advance with all due sincerity.
> > >
> > > If my usual "leafeater/tianyue" addy shows up here but not on
> > your
> > > site, then someone at your end changed it, period. Case
> > closed.
> > >
> > > Maybe one of your other moderators did it, or maybe you did it
> > by
> > > mistake. If it wasn't deliberate, perhaps someone familiar with
> > yahoo
> > > groups moderation can explain how it could possibly be an
> > error. If
> > > it is an error on your part, I apologize.
> > >
> > > Leaf
> > >
> > >
> > > --- In email@example.com, "prometheus_973"
> > > <prometheus_973@> wrote:
> > > >
> > > > Leaf,
> > > >
> > > > I approved your post as you sent it. I didn't change anything
> > > > to reveal your name. You did it, not me! Seems like I'm
> > damned
> > > > if I do and damned if I don't. I don't know what to do for you
> > > > at this point really. I can't appease you in anything I try
> > > > Tell you what, just post on the other sites. People will read
> > > > there. All this cross posting isn't necessary anyway. But
> > please
> > > > stop blaming ESA for everything that doesn't seem right to
> > you.
> > > >
> > > > Prometheus
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > --- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "tomleafeater"
> > > > <tianyue@> wrote:
> > > > >
> > > > > Update on the events at ESA:
> > > > >
> > > > > I notice a strange new develeopment. They posted my new
> > post (I
> > > > > thjank them for that), but switched to my other email
> > address
> > > which
> > > > > reveals my actual name.
> <snipped for redundancy reasons! by Liz ;-)>
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>