1166Re: Web Upload for Faros
- Nov 11, 2008Hi Alex (G7KSE)
Yes, that is much the same experience I had. The problem is not with
the auto uploaders, but with the FTP servers at the website, they will
timeout and drop the link if there is no traffic for a (short) period of
time... As we have no control of that end, we are "stuffed" as we'd
If there is an automatic FTP uploaded, that will itself close the link
when the job is done, and then make a new connection when the next batch
is ready, that is what we need, even on a file by file basis if need be.
I have the tools to make such a program, but I don't sadly have the
spare time for that (or many other things I'd like to do, not just
radio, PC's etc)
There are two conflicting requirements. To close the link when the
batch work is done, and to detect when exactly that work is done. None
of the automatic uploaders I've tried can it seems do either of them.
I did some experiments with WinSCP and a FTP server of my own, and if
you configure the server NOT to time out the clients connection, then
WinSCP, AutoFTP etc work just fine all the time. BUT...
If the connection is lost, (a network "burp" etc) then the server will
not close the connection, and eventualy will exhaust it's network
sockets resources, so you can see why just about all FTP servers will
timeout a client at some point if there is no traffic. That and most
clients inability to cleanly detect a failed link, and remake it, is the
The other problem, telling when the batch job is done, in some ways is
easy, but if it's just sitting there monitoring the file system for
changes, it has no way of telling that things are "done" for now, just
because no changes have been made for a while. Unless you found one, I
have not found one that will itself drop the link to the server cleanly,
after a period of no local changes.
Scheduled uploaders. Is probably the overall best way to go at the
moment. They should connect to the server, shovel the data, and
disconnect, nothing else. The problem is to get the schedule timing
right so the website does not fall too far behind Faros, and conversely
not to create too many unneeded updates. I guess if Faros is set to
update the data files every quater hour say, then the sheduler could run
every 7 1/2 minutes. Just an example, I have Faros updating the GIF's
every hour here, so a sheduled upload every half hour, or triggered at
specific minutes past the hour perhaps. Then you need to synchronise
the PC's clock too, more fun and games!...
> MessagesYeah, as if I'm ever going to click on that! I broke the link just to
> 1. You have received an important Message!
> Posted by: "hysfbce" hysfbce@... hysfbce
> Date: Sun Nov 9, 2008 5:59 pm ((PST))
> You have received an important Message! Check it here:
> ht tp://byd yvfu.zo omshare.com/fi les/ke nny.htm
Ignore it folks! No matter how well protected you may think you are, if
you cause your system to down load a malicious web page, you can still
get a nasty suprise, and not always imediatly!
I'm not saying that page is know to be bad, but this is how the bad guys
> Messages in this topic (1)
> 2a. Re: Web Upload for Faros
> Posted by: "g7kse" g7kse@... g7kse
> Date: Mon Nov 10, 2008 4:49 am ((PST))
> Where do I start. I tried a whole heap of different client.
> WinSCP - Did the upload fine but timed out and couldn't keep
> alive AutoFTP from Primasoft - As WinSCP AUTOftp Manager -
> Worked but being married to a Scot a free solution was what I
> was after.
> CoreFTP - Done on a schedule rather than as a syncro service.
> Worked well.
> FTP Synchronizer - Expensive but worked
> Carbon FTP - Never got off the ground as I found the Glen
> Delahoy AutoFTP
> I struggled so hard to make the keep alive part working that
> I ended up giving up and ended up using a macro recorder and
> scheduler in XP to run it. The ftp part was the biggest
> headache and still isn't failsafe on my system.
> I'm planning on a pc upgrade so I'm hoping that if I switch
> to a better motherboard then it'll not give out the errors so
> --- In email@example.com, "Dave" <dave@...> wrote:
> > Hi Alex, The only problem I had was the time out and disconnect
> on idle. I need a keep-alive feature I guess. I have another
> FTP program that does that but won't upload on file change.
> What other FTP clients are available other that SCR?
> > Thanks a million,
> > Dave
> > ----- Original Message -----
> > From: Dave Baxter
> > To: firstname.lastname@example.org
> > Sent: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 10:34 AM
> > Subject: RE: [dxatlas] Web Upload for Faros
> > Alex (G7KSE)
> > If you ever need to host your own Faros page, let me know, and
> I'll walk
> > you through what I had to do, not only with the mini web server
> > but the Router "Adjustments" needed to allow it all to work, and
> > secure.
> > With a suitable PC, it should be posible to have Faros, and the
> web page
> > server all on one box. It's a pitty it still needs an external
> > source, or you could use it when out portable away from the 'net.
> > (Mobile GPRS or 3G based 'net, does not cut the mustard, oh how
> > tried!)
> > 73
> > Dave G0WBX.
> > > -----Original Message-----
> > > 1a. Re: Web Upload for Faros
> > > Posted by: "g7kse" g7kse@... g7kse
> > > Date: Tue Nov 4, 2008 1:36 am ((PST))
> > >
> > > --- In email@example.com, "Dave Baxter" <dave@>
> > > >
> > > > Hi...
> > > >
> > > > At the moment I host my own web site so the auto FTP upload
> > > isn't an
> > > > issue for me, yet. However I did it this way as like Alex
> > > (G7KSE) I
> > > > had lots of problems with WinSCP, not least that most
> servers will
> > > > auto disconnect you, if there is no traffic between you and
> > > them, 15
> > > > minutes was way too long! Any less, and I'd risk the ISP
> > > > complaining about something.
> > > >
> > > > Dave G0WBX (G8KBV)
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> > > Hi Dave (G0WBX). As you can see with the script I'm still
> > > with Wordpress, VE3SUN's pages are really useful if you are
> > > build pages up from scratch and I totally agree with you
> > > about Kompozer (Nvu). Easy to use and well supported. As for
> > > the self host. I tried setting something up locally and I
> > > have to say that it was beyond me. Perhaps I need to do some
> > > more learning before trying again. Really good to know that
> > > there is an expert looking on though.
> > >
> > >
> > > Dave (KA0SWT)
> > > That stuff I posted was the full template from my wordpress
> > > site. I see also that you've given it a try on XAMPP. Perhaps
> > > I should do the same and see if it'll work for me. What theme
> > > are you usung and I'll try and copy that on my machine.
> > >
> > > Alex
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>