Re: [disabilitystudies] Terrorism, MLATs, the Patriot Act turning the rule of law on its ass
- Most interesting, Keith. Thanks very much for this. I've been doing a lot of research lately into the Patriot Act and various other agreements between Canada and the U.S. in an effort to determine what Canadians can expect from our officials in the way of support when U.S. actions appear contrary to our policies. There is a case right now before the U.S. Supreme Court in which three guys from the U.S. brought maybe $3 million in U.S. liquor to Canada w/o paying our sin tax. The U.S. decided to prosecute and not by way of a smuggling charge but on the basis of wire fraud, which attracts something called civil forfeiture. It's not clear from the decisions rendered so far whether this has happened already or even which country would be entitled to the tax money. If the conviction stands, it means the U.S. will have steamrolled over about 300 years of common law, which has said quite clearly throughout the ages that no country will uphold another country's tax law; our own is already too weird and complex for most of us.Louise's theory: America has a big expensive war to fight and civil forfeiture in the U.S. is a hugely important revenue source. The Busher is seeking 'creative' ways to finance Iraq. Civil forfeiture is one of them. With expanded international agreements with 26 countries, the U.S. may be clearing a path for further expansion in this regard. How hard would it be for Uncle Sam, armed with MLATs, the Patriot Act and anti-terrorist legislation enacted in each country in response to 9/11, to enter a foreign jurisdiction like Canada and start seizing assets on the basis, for example, of what Sam believes is reasonable probable cause that a business has 'terrorist associations'? Would Paul Martin's gov't defend us, I wonder?Louise
Keith Armstrong <keitharm@...> wrote:
He is known to the outside world only as "P". Nearly two years ago,
he was arrested without charge and imprisoned as an alleged foreign
terrorist - an al-Qa'ida sympathiser who threatens Britain's national
But P is now in a mental ward in Broadmoor secure hospital, one of
four men arrested as suspect terrorists since September 11 who have
suffered a severe mental collapse. And he is an alleged terrorist who
has no arms.
Until now, few details have emerged about P, but The Independent on
Sunday has learnt that the man, a single north African male in his
30s who came to Britain as a refugee, has lost one forearm with the
other arm amputated above the elbow.
His lawyer, Gareth Peirce, claims that P's experiences highlight
precisely why nine Law Lords produced their devastating attack last
Thursday on the Government's powers to intern suspected foreign
Lord Hoffman, the most senior Law Lord, described the powers as "the
real threat to the life of the nation". Other Law Lords branded them
as "clearly" discriminatory and unjustifiably draconian.
Ever since his arrest in January last year, P's story has become
intimately wrapped up with the life of another detainee, another
north African man known as "B".
Also in his 30s, B became P's closest friend when they were
incarcerated together in Belmarsh high-security prison in south
London. B became his carer and cellmate, giving his friend the most
basic assistance possible: help with dressing, eating and washing. Ms
Peirce alleges that P was effectively helpless when he was jailed,
and had no false arms or disability aids.
"He had had prosthetic arms but had been arrested two years earlier,
and the police had broken those arms. They'd actually caused
wholesale damage. With that whole experience, he has never been able
to bring himself to try them again," Ms Peirce said.
The close relationship between the two men continues. As The
Independent on Sunday revealed last week, both men became so mentally
disturbed by their isolation and detention without trial, they were
in a "life-threatening condition".
In October and November, the two men were separately sent to
Broadmoor for specialist psychiatric care.
B's mental collapse, alleges Ms Peirce, was finally caused by the
closure of a pottery class at Belmarsh. A skilled artist and potter,
B had found escape in the class, in one case taking two years to
fashion an elaborately decorated Islamic vase which was coveted by
the prison's guards. Closure of the class, she said, "became the
Their transfer to Broadmoor meant that a third of the current
detainees under the Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001 have
been officially diagnosed as severely mentally ill.
One man, a Palestinian named Abu Rideh, went to Broadmoor after
attempting suicide and suffering a mental breakdown following an
attempted hunger strike.
A fourth detainee, "G", is living under extremely tight bail
restrictions with his wife and children at home - restrictions that
effectively ban him from leaving the house, making phone calls,
having visitors or using his garden.
G, who is wheelchair-bound with polio, was bailed by the Special
Immigration Appeals Commission, a secretive tribunal set up by David
Blunkett, the then Home Secretary, because of his mental collapse. Mr
Blunkett famously described the tribunal's decision as "bonkers".
Last week, the new Home Secretary, Charles Clarke, indicated that the
Government would insist on keeping the men detained, a stance some
observers believe Mr Clarke will gradually soften.
As with other detainees, the Government alleges G was linked to a
hard-line Islamist terror group in the al-Qa'ida network, in his case
the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group. They accuse him of providing false
documents and money to extremists.
B is alleged to have belonged to an Algerian extremist group, and to
have helped find communications gear and other supplies for Algerian
and Chechen terrorists.
The most notorious detainee is Abu Qatada, the Jordanian cleric
alleged to be al-Qa'ida's "spiritual leader" in Europe and a "highly
One former Belmarsh inmate told The Independent on Sunday yesterday
that the summary arrest and internment of the men was causing them to
go slowly mad. The former inmate, a Kenyan who gave his name
as "Ahmed", said: "You could see the stress and anxiety on their
faces. It is really destroying them, and I don't think many will
survive, even if they are released today. Many of them have been
Ahmed was arrested under separate immigration legislation for
allegedly helping to plot the bombings of the US embassies in Kenya
and Tanzania in August 1998, claims the intelligence services
eventually admitted were unfounded.
Now with temporary leave to remain in Britain, he was held in
Belmarsh for 14 months, and met the terror detainees every Friday at
prayers and during education periods.
"They feel they're being used for political purposes and were
arrested to create fear in the public," he said. "They know they're
no threat. They feel that if they had a fair trial, they could prove
to the public they're not a threat. They say they escaped as refugees
to this country for safety and justice: it's ludicrous for them to be
described as a threat to this country."
More goto: story=594575>
By Severin Carrell 19 December 2004 Indy.
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar.
Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free!
To Subscribe, please send a blank message to: disabilitystudies-subscribe@...
To Unsubscribe, please send a blank message to: disabilitystudies-unsubscribe@...
To Post a message, send it to: disabilitystudies@...
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
Post your free ad now! Yahoo! Canada Personals