Reed: FCC Order on Comcast - a good job
- (Guarding the standards-making process -- and these particular
standards, which by their general purpose nature not only make
possible the full diversity of applications that the Internet platform
supports, but also make possible the flexible development of standards
in itself -- is a critical line of attack in assuring "net
neutrality." The DPS Project is distinct and derives a considerable
part of its strength and appeal because of its addressing and
recognizing this approach and concern: http://www.dpsproject.com --
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: FCC Order on Comcast - a good job (FCC decision link
Date: Wed, 20 Aug 2008 14:23:13 -0400
From: "David P. Reed" <dpreed@...>
To: Seth Johnson <seth.johnson@...>
Friends - I just posted this on my blog, regarding the FCC opinion and
order about Comcast RST injection. Feel free to send a pointer to it
anyone interested The comment I sent to the Commissioners is also
-David P. Reed
FCC Order on Comcast - a good job <http://www.reed.com/blog-dpr/?p=12>
The FCC today issued its formal opinion and order in regard to
degrading of P2P and other traffic using DPI and RST injection
Of course, Ive been very interested in this, especially since I was
asked by the Commission to testify as a witness at the en banc hearing
at Harvard Law School in February.
After reading the order this morning, I felt like commending the FCC -
so I filed a formal comment with the FCC, and I posted it on my site
<http://www.reed.com/blog-dpr/?page_id=10> as well. The decision is a
good decision for the Internet. In short heres why:
The decision shows that the agency understands the importance of the
technological principles of the Internets design.
The Internet is a /world-wide system that does not belong to any one
operator/, whether providing access lines or backbone transport.
The design of the Internet Protocols specifies clear limits on what
operators can and cannot do to Internet Protocol datagrams when those
operators are acting as part of the Internet.
Not obeying those limits poses a serious risk to the continued success
of the world-wide Internet. Happily, the FCC recognized and exposed
Comcasts transgressions of those limits.
Though Internet design is not a law, the Commissions order respects
importance of that design, and rejects Comcasts misbehavior and
deception in applying technologies that go against the principles of