Re: [XTalk] Re: Discipleship
- At 08:56 AM 9/7/2004, John E Staton wrote:
>Bob,That would be my point <g>
> I don't think we differ too much on the wider question. I am certainly
>not a propounder of double predestination, and would (if anything) interpret
>"cannot" in the weaker sense except where the stronger sense is reqired by
>the context. As for who is (was) a disciple, I am sure it was not such an
>open and shut case.
> Have you read Jimmy Dunn's thoughts on "Circles of Discipleship" inNo; what's he say?
> "Jesus Remembered"?
Robert M. Schacht, Ph.D.
University of Hawaii
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
From memory, he suggests there were various "circles of discipleship"
around Jesus, ranging from the "inner three" and the twelve at one end, to
people who turned up whenever Jesus was in the neighbourhood at the other.
In between we have the women who provided for his needs. There may also have
been "regional" disciples (i.e they may have followed him around Galilee,
but not accompanied him to Jerusalem. Not all of these will have "given up
everything", and some may have remained members of their local communities.
It may, however, be wise to do a bit of source criticism to
determine how much of the forgoing is Jimmy Dunn, and how much is me.
JOHN E STATON
Penistone, Sheffield UK