169943Re: Adverbial verbs(like stative verbs)?
- Feb 1, 2010----- "R A Brown" <ray@...> wrote:
> Philip Newton wrote:In Chinese, "tomorrow" is a noun and no inflection is required (Tomorrow is the day after the first day of the rest of your life.) (I'll go there tomorrow.). "There" is a noun. "Then", temporally, is "that time" (I was just a child then.). Causally, it could be "(as a) result" (If it's Tuesday, then it must be Belgium.). Sequentially, maybe something like "le lendemain", but for the next moment (I went to the train station, then I bought a magazine.)
> > That works well for adverbs that are related to
> adjectives ("in an ADJ
> > manner", for example). But "adverb", at least in some
> descriptions of
> > some languages, is also a catch-all class for all sorts
> of particles
> > such as "tomorrow" and "there".
> Yep - practically all the discussion so far has related to
> what we, back in the 1950s, called "adverbs of manner" and,
> indeed, solely to descriptive adjectives; and as it has been
> pointed out, there is no real problem in dispensing with the
> category "adverb [of manner]." Many natlangs don't have a
> discrete category for them.
> 'Tomorrow' may, of course, be used as a noun, so presumably
> this can have some noun flexion. But 'there' ("adverb of
> place") and 'then' ("adverb of time") seem to me a little
> When I saw Philip's 'there', my immediate response was "[in]Vincent didn't say compound nouns were out of bounds, so why not just let it be a (pro)noun: "He doesn't like that." That way, "that place" and "that time" are compound nouns like "firehouse". If you allow compound nouns, you might also get some differences in meaning:
> that place." Then I thought "Hey, how's Vincent going to
> express 'that'? It's adjectival, but a stative verb doesn't
> seem appropriate."
be-fast train - a fast train
fastness (i.e. speed) train - an express
As for "*in* that place", (back to Chinese), make "in" a noun: that place('s) inside. "zhuo1zi shang4", "on the table" is "(the) table('s) 'on-top-of-ness'", so you can get things like:
Shang4 you3 tian1tang2 Above has Heaven
Xia4 you3 Su1Hang2 Below has Suzhou and Hangzhou
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>