Re: [civilwarwest] Re: McMurry Review Citation
- In a message dated 5/5/2004 1:01:44 PM Eastern Daylight Time, dmsmith001@... writes:
> The McDonough Atlanta book was, to the best of myI owned his Shiloh book long before the Atlanta one
> knowledge, McDonough's first.
came out. The Atlanta book has a 1991 publication
date (I *think*) and Amazon indicates the Shiloh book
was published in 1983.
I think his work is very superficial. Most of us could
do as well.
I do recall, before I learned of the plagerism issue,
seeing folks refer to Castel's book as the *first*
book-length treatment of the campaign, and wondering
why the McDonough-Jones book was being ignored.