45648Re: Was Logan dissed for higher command?
- Jul 10, 2008--- In firstname.lastname@example.org, "Carl Williams" <carlw4514@...>
> Finished the book "Black Jack: John A. Logan and Southern Illinois
> the Civil War Era" I Recommend it.the
> The author discusses whether Logan was unjustly passed over as a
> replacement for McPherson when he was KIA. Interestingly, he gave
> Sherman's views on what he didnt like about "political generals."
> Seems that there is more to it than unthinking prejudice. I loaned
> book to someone, so can't quote from it, but basically Sherman justlittle
> felt that these guys typically just weren't full time. He was
> especially resentful when they would go home to campaign for
> reelection just as things were critical in the field.
> I have to admit Sherman has a case there, if true.
> Makes you wonder if the prejudice against non-west point was a
> more founded in solid reasons than you might think."Sherman fighting Prophet" by Lloyd Lewis,says Sherman was thinking of
putting Logan to take over for Mac. but Thomas was very much against
it and talked Sherman out of it. BvT
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>