Re: OT: on culture war
- --- In firstname.lastname@example.org, Donna-Lee Phillips
> I didn't say anything about sex acts.
> > If I make a movie that depicts a sex act that you (or others)
> > consider to be "harmful," why is that an abuse of free
> I certainly didn't say anything about sex acts that I (or others)
> consider to be "harmful".
> I didn't say that was an abuse of free speech.
> > It's all down to your own perception. Like I said in an earlier
> > it's "freedom" when you like it, "license" when you don't. Larryof
> > Flynt is no more "abusing" his freedom of speech, freedom
> > the press, and freedom of expression than the feministwho's
> > saying she doesn't like "Hustler."about
> I didn't say anything about Larry Flynt, and I didn't say anything
> "Hustler" (although they gave my book a shitty review).With
> What I say is just this, and no more... absolutely nothing more:
> freedom comes responsibility.perform
> And everyone has the freedom not to watch, read, listen to or
> anything they find offensive.I agree. But Rick and I were discussing "indecency" in public
(nipplegate) and in the public arena (magazines, etc.). You
weren't specific when you made your comments, so I figured you
were on about what we were on about. What WERE you on
about, then? Verbal harassment?
Yes, people have the freedom to not watch, etc.
My point is, quite simply, the government has no role to play in
matters of speech, "indecent" or otherwise.
- --- Larry <larrytheillini@...> wrote:
>Actually, I was speaking of the General You, since I
> --- In email@example.com, Rick Sharer
> <rlsharer@y...> wrote:
> > > Heh. You're dodging the question. How do I
> > > properly answer "So,
> > > Daddy, YOU believe in God, right?"
> > Properly? Truthfully.
> > Properly in the context of not upsetting your
> > You lie like a dog.
> > It's your choice.
> > ...
> > Choosing to raise your child in a belief system
> > you do not believe is pure hypocrisy, usually
> > by spousal compromise...ergo, there is inherent
> > controversy.
> You're misunderstanding the situation and making an
> awfully big
> assumption (though probably the inevitable one)
> about my wife.
don't really know enough about your situation to make
a call one way or another. I apologize if it sounded
like I was calling *you* a hypocrite...I was speaking
about anybody, including me.
You mentioned (in a question) that you may do
something similar, but again, I don't have enough
> I'm not trying to pretend to believe in God so thatThat's cool. Again, not going after you. :)
> Laurel will. But
> I'm also not trying to raise her as a freak like
> Madeline Murray
> O'Hair's kid who was all messed up because his
> mother had "kept" him
> from God. She's going to have to be familiar with
> the concept.
> What I was asking you personally was whether it wasThe answer is the same. It is a sin to lie, it is not
> sinful for an
> atheiest to lie to his kid to encourage the kid to
> believe in God.
> Or is it better to tell the truth, which is that
> Daddy is an atheist,
> which probably leads to the kid (at least for many
> years) being one
a sin to raise a child in Truth...there are multiple
things going on in your hypothetical. :)
> It was more hypothetical than you took it,Again, I didn't intend my explanation to be anything
> because I don't
> intend to lie to her.
> But first we'll work on SantaHeh.
> Claus. Atheism
> can wait a few years.
> She's not being raised Catholic, if that's whatWhew.
> you're concerned
> about. ;)
> Nonetheless, lying is not an elemental prohibitionHowever, "bearing false witness" *is* addressed,
> in the ten
> commandments. It doesn't belong with "killing,
> cheating, stealing"
> which are.
precisely because the effects of such can lead to
> > That's never been confirmed,Easy.
> Can four million Evangelicals be wrong? ;)
> > and if Bush becomesNot for long!
> > instrumental in creating a Peace in the middle
> > I'm going to be a lot less confident in that
> > assertion.
> I'll be right there to say "I told you so." Heh.
Do you Yahoo!?
Send holiday email and support a worthy cause. Do good.