Re: You need less space living in a good neighborhood
- --- In carfree_cities@y..., "justinemarysmith"
> In United States perhaps a small handful ofHardly. I live in Austin, Texas, in the Hyde
> cities have neighborhoods as you describe.
> Do you live in Europe or Canada?
Park neighborhood. Much of Austin has become the
typically sprawled city. But there are a handful
of neighborhoods that are pretty convenient. I
suspect the majority of people, in major cities
throughout the US, (a) don't know that their
cities contain such neighborhoods, and (b) are
unaware of how much difference it makes, compared
to living in the typical suburb.
> Do you live in Europe or Canada?I live in Canada, specifically, Ottawa, the national capital and fourth
I live in "the Glebe" (the name refers to the status of the lands before
development, as lands belonging to a downtown church, used to rent to
farmers, giving the church extra income). It is about a square mile,
with a population of about 12,000 in about 8,000 households, half of
which are rented. We are served by two north-south and two east-west
We have about 100 retail outlets, which are less neighbourhood-oriented
than before the car became ubiquitous. But we do have the following:
2 grocery stores, plus about 20 other food stores (including 3 bakeries)
2 liquor stores and 2 beer stores (they are government monopolies in
38 restaurants and take-outs, including 7 pubs (they stay open until 2
1 laundromat (two closed in the last two years)
1 hardware store
2 video outlets (plus a few videos avail. at 3 remaining corners stores)
1 pet-supply store, plus three vets
2 gas stations and one repair garage
10 bookstores (there were 15 ten years ago)
2 community centres (one for seniors)
3 elementary schools, 1 high school, 1 montessori school
5 coffee shops (our tea house closed about 4 years ago)
Thanks to high property values and slow driving speeds on our main
street (Bank Street), very few chains have moved in: Body Shop,
Pizza-Pizza and Pizza hut, and McDonalds (not on the main street,
though). A good sign of commercial health is the growing number of new
businesses that locate around the corner, in basements, and on second
floors (there are also a number of apartments above stores).
And, yes, these amenities translate into needing less space to live in.
And, with 1) transit, 2) a high likelihood of flagging down a taxi on an
arterial, and 3) two car-sharing vehicles (provided by my company,
Vrtucar), there is little reason to own a car (a major exception is poor
transit service for "reverse commutes" to the suburban business parks,
which means that street parking is tight overnight).
I have often thought of developing a "neighbourhood integrity" index to
find the most self-sufficient neighbourhood in North America. I would
think ours (which my wife and I "discovered" in 1981, although we lived
in it when we were married in 1969 before moving to the burbs where our
parents urged us to live) would be among the top "scorers."
In general, Canadian cities have a number of "advantages" over American
cities. With the climate, we have smaller yards, emphasizing indoor
space. With more unified municipal government, we have more compact new
development and few "poor neighbourhoods." With more racial integration
(and a smaller population of "blacks"), we never experienced
neighbourhood upheavals. With no federal powers over urban affairs, we
don't have the downside of strings-attached grants to build urban
freeways and clear, wholesale, older urban areas. I also think (I was
raised in a Canadian-American family, living the last half of childhood
in Ohio and Denver, and attending a U.S. college) that Canadians are
less gung-ho consumers, having a more cynical view of advertising (e.g.,
I think there are more Canadian top comics in our common entertainment
market than there are Americans).
- --- In carfree_cities@y..., Chris Bradshaw <chris@t...> wrote:
> I have often thought of developing a "neighbourhoodHopefully, we would not all move to that one. But
> integrity" index to find the most self-sufficient
> neighbourhood in North America.
there IS a tremendous difference between neighborhoods,
in the same city. Even cities that suffer sprawl and
other problems sometimes contain neighborhoods that are
quite convenient. And the identity of these
neighborhoods now seems almost a secret. Sometimes not
even the local real estate agents know and appreciate
the difference -- they just remark in surprise that
"those small houses sure maintain their value."
I think a catalog of good neighborhoods would attract
a lot of attention to the qualities we're discussing,
and might even make a successful book. I'm not sure
how to put it together. I don't think it is enough to
develop a numerical metric and then score neighborhoods,
even if one could get the raw data for the score. How
many restaurants, banks, groceries, bars, video stores,
etc. are within a mile of my house? So many, it would
take quite some work to count. More important than
their distance "as the crow flies" is that they are on
good walking routes. Now: Where do you get *that* kind
It seems to me that such a catalog almost has to be
compiled by someone who investigates such things in a
more direct fashion than running city directories
through a computer program, though that might be a