Re: [bolger] Re: Super Brick
- Hi Stefan,
Thanks for explaining the proper interpretation of my Super Brick
Challenge proposal. It seems you understood everything on my web site
very well. I appreciate your clarification and thanks for your wishes
There is another value here that you forgot to mention however ...
I plan to produce a detailed and profusely illustrated Super Brick
Construction Guide from this project. I think this resource will provide
a very good value to most contributors, especially those who cannot come
to the Philippines and sail the boat personally.
I will put this resource online free of charge for those supporters who
"meet the challenge". Everyone else can pay for access to this
information, similar to the way duckworks charges non-supporters for
access to certain portions of their web site. At least this is my
current plan ... :)
>1) James Greene is not a professional boatbuilder.
> This alone would make your post pointless.
>2) James has been on this list since a long time,
> and has actively posted. I personally have benefitted
> from this. IMHO, people who give to a community,
> are "entitled" also to take something from it.
>3) James' operation is no set-up boatbuilding shop,
> but he wants to start one. What he asks for is not
> investment (i.e. the start-up money that you are talking
> about), but money for the cost of the first boat,
> that he would build without financial gain for himself
> (except some advertising benefits).
> If you want, the only ones who gain are the carpenters,
> since they would earn money to feed their families.
> (Isn't it always said, that trade is the best development
>4) You write: "Let them get an actual customer that will
> finance the building...". The original pledge was the form
> of a donation to the builder. James has however turned it
> around and is exactly doing what you propose:
> He is trying to find a group of customers who would pay
> for a boat and where they would get direct benefits
> from their contributions (use of the boat).
> Since he can produce at low cost, and high quality
> (he is experienced carpenter), his customers can expect
> a good value for their contributions to this project.
>I am in no position to comment on the feasibility (IMHO looks good),
>but I think his approach is very fair to everybody, and I wish him and
>the group good success.