51950Re: water ballast vs lead, iron, etc
- Dec 1, 2006Graeme,
You are absolutly right in observing that the lifting of the boat
begins as soon as the angle deviates from zero. Hence, the linear
relation between torque and angle is never strictly true. I believe
(hope) that this effect is sufficiently small in most boats. This
needs to be checked, either numerically or experimentally.
Regarding your second comment, we didn't add the fishing weights, but
shifted them "leeward" from the "windward" side. There was no "wind"
of course, and the actual force of the sails on the boat are
complicated and dynamic. Though unable to model all complexities, I
believe our experiment exactly matched what computer stability codes do.
Enjoyed your commentary,
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>