Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

1601Re: [beemonitoring] mesh to exclude honey bees

Expand Messages
  • Jack Neff
    Jun 2, 2011
    • 0 Attachment
      Did you consider constructing mesh enclosures with varying size mesh, placing different bee species inside, and seeing who got out?  If they can get out, presumably they can get in.  This would be a direct test of the exclusionary powers of various meshes.  You're sort of doomed anyway with this sort of experiment since there are many non-Apis bees who are very close to Apis size (Apis of course meaning mellifera, the other Apis species would cause a different set of problems) and no mesh size will solve that problem.

      best

      Jack
       
      John L. Neff
      Central Texas Melittological Institute
      7307 Running Rope
      Austin,TX 78731 USA
      512-345-7219

      From: Nicholas Stewart <nick.s2art@...>
      To: Hannah Gaines <hgaines@...>; beemonitoring@yahoogroups.com; David_r_smith@...; Sam Droege <sdroege@...>; John Pickering <pick@...>
      Sent: Thursday, June 2, 2011 1:40 PM
      Subject: Re: [beemonitoring] mesh to exclude honey bees

       
      Hello Hannah & Group;

         Interesting you brought this up - per my project (now well w/in the 2nd year of my native GA pollinator assessment & inventory in N GA apple orchards), we recieved federal funding to conduct an Apis exclusionary program. We, prior to the bloom, but during bud formation, chose random clumps of branches on the trees at varying heights throughout two of my orchards. Around these we built boxes of a standard square footage using mesh (the most difficult part of the ENTIRE darn thing was finding the correct mesh diameter) to exclude Apis, while still allowing as many of the Andrenids, Colletids, and Halictids to enter (as well as any pollinating syrphids, muscoids, etc.). After we were sure the flowers within the devices were unavailble for further fertilization, we removed the boxes. We have, subsequently, been monitoring the branches of interest each time we go to the sites for sampling days - ultimately hoping to see whether the most common native apoidea witnessed/quantified in 2010 were able to provide the necessary pollination services Apis-free equivalent to conditions when present.

      As part of the funding, I'll be publishing this data & methods later this year, but I can warn you that there are sooooo many options for the exclusionary material, you need to test every material prior to field implementation, as honeybees are little houdini's!

      Per Mr. Smith's follow-up questions; yes, larger buzz-pollinating behemoths were excluded as well. From my 2010 findings during the bloom, the majority of Apoid species present in the highest abundances were smaller than Apis. If we ultimately find late this summer/fall that the Apis-free branches produced similar yields & similar quality apples (i.e. - june drops vs bag/cider vs show/store apples), than we can preliminarily sumise that natives are surely capable of handling the pollination services necessary to this orchard - its only a plus that the larger natives will be present in nature, further ensuring a good yield/fruit quality.

      Hope that helped,
      Nick Stewart

      On Mon, May 23, 2011 at 9:32 AM, Hannah Gaines <hgaines@...> wrote:
       
      Hello Bee Monitoring List
      I am setting up an experiment in which I would like to compare fruit set with and without honey bees (or small versus large bees).  To do this I am building mesh cages which I am hoping will exclude honey bees but allow the smaller native bees.  The mesh I am considering using is 1/6 of an inch (usually used to exclude Japanese beetles).  My questions are:

      1. Will a 1/6 inch mesh exclude honey bees?
      2. Will bees smaller than honey bees fly through a 1/6 inch mesh?

      Thanks!
      Hannah


      --
      ________________________________________
      Hannah R. Gaines
      http://entomology.wisc.edu/%7Egaines/



      --
      Nicholas G. Stewart
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Georgia Native Fruit Tree -----------------------------------------------------------------------
      -------------------------------- Pollinator Biodiversity Assessment, 
      (2010-13) 
      ----------------- Managing Native Pollinator Species Richness:   Efforts in Sustainable, Native Pollination Services -------
           Project Design   ---   Lead Field Researcher   ---   Primary Taxonomist
      nick.s2art@...   *(PRIMARY)*   
      nstewart@...                                                                                         (404) 784-6236            



    • Show all 5 messages in this topic