10RE: [bacnet-ip-wg] SGD-004-05 - Network Object
- Feb 6, 2006Stuart,I have a few comments on the network object document:- Under table 12-13 there is a footnote indicateing that "MAC_Address" "May be writable for MS/TP networks." Any property in the standard may be writable unless explicitly restricted. If the intent is to only allow it to be writable for MS/TP then the footnote should be changed. I would not support such an approach (it should be allowed to be writable for any medium, IMHO).- In a number of places the text indicates "...the MAC_Address will the IP address... " which is incorrect. It will be the IP adress and the IP port - in a specific order which I don't recall right at this moment.- X.12 Baud_Rate - "This property in only applicable if the Network_Type is MS/TP" Applicable or present? Would this not also make sense for PTP? Or even Ethernet if you can query the card to determine if it is 10/100/1000? Maybe it should contain a specific value if the baud-rate is either not known or not applicable.- IP_DHCP_Enable - The language for this property should be changed to be similar to the language that is used for Enable in other objects.- Media_Instance - How does one relate the Media Instance to an actual hardware port in cases where the OS does not provide a 0 based instance (such as where the OS provides strings instead). Would it not be better to accomplish this mapping information through user documentation and/or Descirption/Object_Name property values?Carl
From: email@example.com [mailto:firstname.lastname@example.org] On Behalf Of Stuart.Donaldson@...
Sent: Tuesday, January 17, 2006 8:51 AM
Subject: [bacnet-ip-wg] SGD-004-05 - Network Object
Here is an updated version of SGD-004 with some additional use cases and resolving some issues that those brought up.
I realize that we don't have a lot of time in Chicago, but it would be great if we have an opportunity to discuss this. Otherwise, I will gladly accept comments via e-mail.
Software Engineering Lead
Alerton / Honeywell
This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System.
For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>