Re: [anti-CED] higher/lower forms....was: The ID General Theory [revis ed]
- On 30 Dec 2005 at 22:39, wayfaringman@... wrote:
>YOU are assuming that there is some magical distinction between
> In a message dated 12/30/05 9:41:36 AM Central Standard Time,
> wayfaringman@... writes:
> The ID General Theory includes the higher forms of biological
> What about the lower forms of biological life?
> It doesn't include the lower forms of life yet
> Any new scientific theory MUST explain both the old data and add
> new knowledge. If ID cannot explain the old data ("lower" life
> forms), then it is inadequate to be used to replace the existing
> theory (evolution) which does.
> You are assuming macroevolution is true when you equate lower
> forms of life with old data. In any case The ID General Theory
> covers all higher forms of life in which blood clotting occurs.
macroevolution and microevolution based on a non-observed
hypothetical barrier whose existence you infer from a poorly-
interpreted verse in Genesis. Moreover, Doolittle has SHOWN that
the blood clotting system in lobsters EVOLVED from a fortuitous
copy of the gene for egg yolk protein. As long as ID simply flat-
out ignores the possibility of such exaptation, it is not science
at all, but badly-done apologetics.
> It could easily cover lower forms if an IC system was givenProbably not, since ID is about rhetorical effect, not scientific
> that applied to them. But this is really not necessary at this
> In a way the special theory covers all life. Since livingI have yet to see ANY theory that would qualify as a SCIENTIFIC
> cells > is common to all life. Perhaps the general theory is
> the special one and the special theory is the general one. In
> any case I have given a theory which all evolutionists thought
> was impossible give.
theory coming from the IDist camp. What I do see is a lot of
political machination, often followed by hasty ass-covering when
the politics get too close to felony perjury for comfort.
It's one thing to lie on the hustings. It's quite another to
fib, under oath in court or in a court deposition.
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.1.371 / Virus Database: 267.14.9/217 - Release Date: 12/30/2005