37616Re: Gandalf Deniers at A_T
- Jun 28, 2008Peter Staudenmaier wrote at WC
Steinar: People like Frank Smith and you are very knowledgible
Frank evidently believes you are an actual critic of Waldorf and anthroposophy,
rather than an anthroposophist posing as a critic. I find this genuinely
remarkable. I've tried in the past to explain to Frank the difference between
credulous reading and critical reading; looks like it didn't sink in."
This credulous reading critic (Peter) answered Steinar at least 3 times, very seriously explaining anthroposophy to him. Now he has the audacious balls to say that I don't know the difference between credulous and critical reading.
And now, to spray audacious icing on the cake, Tom Mellett (at A-W) claims that Steinar Beider (Stone worker) is really Tarjei. But we know, dear A_T friends, that Uncle Taz would never condescend to be a Norwegian Troll - don't we?
--- In email@example.com, "Frank Thomas Smith" <eltrigal78@...> wrote:
> A Waldorf-Critic-Creature has unearthed Gandalf deniers at this site.
> This is undeniably a shameful situation and, with all due respect to the
> Powers that Be, I suggest that they be immediately banned (the Gandalf
> deniers, not the Powers that Be).
> "I took a look at that group site. Frank Thomas Smith also ridiculed my
> post about Tolkien's racism and he quoted all I wrote about that with
> a big laugh.
> But I was not the person that thought this out, it came from a very
> straight web site with proper references. I did very much digging in
> the archives at Anthroposophy Tomorrow, and there was much
> antisemitism, one man was very angry against Jews because they were
> Christ-deniars and then a Tolkien-man said that the same Jews were
> also Gandalf-deniars. And Gandalf is from Tolkien's Lord of the Rings.
> As agnostic, I am also guilty of those things, you do not have to be
> Jewish to deny Christ and Gandalf, but this shows that Tolkien-people
> are not only metaphysical fairy tale racists but also real-life
> antisemitic racists just like theosophists and anthroposophists and
> others that believe in the Aryan myth and the swastika."
> P.S. This guy or gal is in a confused state of soul. He compulsively
> spells deniers "deniars" and Steiner "Steinar".
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>