Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Is this a bug in Chap 23.2 ?

Expand Messages
  • ¼B¤j¤¸
    Is this a bug in Chap 23.2 ? On p. 841, line -7, we can rank documents based on the score: P(r|D,Q)/P(~r|D,Q)=... then on p. 842, line 1, With the
    Message 1 of 1 , Jul 28, 2004
    • 0 Attachment
      Is this a bug in Chap 23.2 ?

      On p. 841, line -7,
      "we can rank documents based on the score:
      P(r|D,Q)/P(~r|D,Q)=...
      "

      then on p. 842, line 1,
      "With the assumption, we get
      P(r|D,Q)/P(~r|D,Q)
      =P(Q|D,r)*P(r|D) / P(~r|D)
      "

      I believe the derivation of the latter has bug.
      What I'd suggest, is:
      P(r|D,Q)/P(~r|D,Q)
      =P(Q|D,r)*P(r|D) / (P(~r|D)*P(Q|D,~r))
      =P(Q|D,r)*P(r|D) / (P(~r|D)*P(Q|~r)) by using the assumption on p.
      841, last line.

      But then the author would need to explain how to calculate the new
      term P(Q|~r)).

      David Liu
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.