1717Re: [agile-usability] RE: norman
- Nov 1, 2005
Re: [agile-usability] RE: normanOn 2/11/05 2:12 AM, "Jade Ohlhauser" <jade@...> wrote:
You have some good points, but I think you're being too harsh on poor Microsoft. Have you used OneNote? It's a great application and finally someone has executed the idea of not having a save dialog at all in a major, useful application.
I too am boggled by the inclusion of favorites and history in the Office save dialog, but as is often the case with UI criticism, you seem to be focusing solely on the bad here. There are definite missteps, but saying the UI is horrid? Word is one application that I've found most people seem to do OK with, and in the grand scheme of computer use, that's saying a lot. Despite the confusing flaws so apparent to us, millions of people manage to overcome the obstacles in Word every day. And I have respect and pity for Microsoft UI people not because of that accomplishment, but because of the legacy burden that unprecedented install base presents to making changes and the wide range of tasks it means trying to solve.
In much the same way, people overcome the extreme difficulty of learning to become a pilot, play the piano, or setting up their new, unusable stereo system. This is where the key word of “motivation” comes into play. Something doesn’t have to be usable, engaging, or even good for millions of people to use it.
I’ve recently moved from Mac OSX Mail to Microsoft’s Entourage because the people I work with have set up MS Exchange. Mail is a simple, elegant application that does all I need in an email client. Entourage is filled with features that for me remain unused, it doesn’t integrate well with the OS (I can’t even search through my emails) and is giving me no end of problems. I’m only using Entourage because my office is on Exchange – not because I want to.
In much the same way as people got stuck with Lotus Notes, the typical business these days is stuck with MS Office and MS Word. Word is one of the most frustrating applications I’ve used (especially when trying to place graphics), but it’s what most of my clients demand.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>