Re: Words and shots (Was: A thought about BLACK NARCISSUS)
- --- In email@example.com, "hotlove666" <hotlove666@y...> wrote:
> --- In firstname.lastname@example.org, Dan Sallitt <sallitt@p...> wrote:Isn't this a wee bit elitist and high-handed, Bill? Couldn't you give
> When I talk about a shot here, I really mean "a shot and how it's
> and/ie who is looking at it. See Pascal Bonitzer's "Voici," which I
> translated moons ago in some academic film publication.
us ignoramuses a clue? What academic film publication and when? And
what about the original text (which I haven't read)? What Cahiers
issue or whatever?
No shot exists in a vacuum of course.
How did you translate "Voici"?
- --- In email@example.com, "Robert Keser" <rfkeser@i...> wrote:
> <hotlove666@y...> wrote:Certainly not of the kind Truffaut used, but Hitchcock always used
> But how does this relate to Hitchcock, apart from sharing the goal
> of inducing anxiety? Thinking literally, I can't recall any such
> object + gesture shots in Hitchcock.
> --Robert Keser
inserts as part of his suspense curves - lighters, keys - and
Truffaut does too, especially at the beginning, when the guy is
racing to the airport. As I recall, time pieces get into the act as
well. But I completely agree that the plethora of inserts calls
attention to itself and to features of the modern world, which as far
as I know is a new point about that film. Again, because for me every
Truffaut film corresponds to a Godard film, look at A Married Woman
for a stylistically different atempt at "French Antonioni."
The other Hitchcockian element in Soft Skin is all the cutting on
looks, which he had used for some of Antoine et Colette, but not the
whole movie. Here it's the whole movie, and the looks are pretty
neutral throughout, a la Hitchcock.
Reportedly, this is the one Truffaut script - writen in an unusual 20-
day spurt - that already contains the decoupage as it appears on
screen, with no room for writing scenes the night before, as was his
I think your point about the inserts raises something interesting
about Truffaut's "Hitchcockism": However immensely he admired
Hitchcock, the Hitchcock style stands for something in a Truffaut
film that it doesn't in a Hitchcock film. Hitchcock style in
Fahrenheit 451 stands for authoritarian mind-control, for example.