Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Germans calling Jews Nazis

Expand Messages
  • Ratna Pelle
    Germans calling Jews Nazis 20.03. 2007 http://www.zionism-israel.com/log/archives/00000365.html Original content copyright by the author Zionism & Israel
    Message 1 of 1 , Mar 19, 2007

      20.03. 2007
      Original content copyright by the author
      Zionism & Israel Center http://zionism-israel.com


      According to a poll carried out in January by the Bertelsmann Foundation, 30 percent of German residents agree that Israel is doing to the Palestinians "what the Nazis did to the Jews in the Third Reich." (Haaretz, March 12)

      Think about it for a second, please: 30% of the Germans think that Israel is trying to exterminate the Palestinians: 'The fence and the checkpoints put them into ghettos, the border police are beating them up like the SS, the re-occupation of Jenin in 2002 resembles the crushing of the Warsaw Ghetto Revolt and in general Israel tries to make life impossible for the Palestinians, which amounts to ethnic cleansing, to create a racist Jews-only state in all of 'Eretz Israel'. Gaza is in fact one big concentration camp.' Thus the reasoning goes. There is just one tiny difference: Israel managed to kill a mere 4,000 Palestinians in 7 years of fighting, whereas the Nazis killed more Jews than that in one day.

      30% of the German people either don't know what the Nazis did to the Jews, or what is happening in Israel and the territories. The first is unlikely, as German media show endless documentaries about the Holocaust, survivors tell their stories, school classes go on excursions to Auschwitz, and the question "What did you do in the war, dad?" has troubled many family relations. The best thing one can do to ruin the career of a public figure is to accuse him of having been a member of the Hitler Jugend or, even worse, of the Waffen SS. A movie about the last days of Hitler, which portrayed him as a human being rather than a devil, sparked a big controversy, but the movie itself marks a significant change in the way Germans look at the past. Apart from the question of whether or not that is a good development, all this shows that Germans are very much dealing with the past and also obsessed with it, because what happened is beyond human understanding. No other country wrestles so much with its history and has so many memorials marking their inky black past, and justly so. For many Germans as well as other Europeans, the Nazis are the symbol of absolute evil.

      As in this light it is hardly conceivable that 30% of the Germans don't know about their past, it seems to follow that they don't know what is going on in Israel and the territories, and sincerely think that Israel is using Nazi methods against the Palestinians. This might in part be due to media coverage of the conflict, that shows the wall (not the fence), Israeli soldiers shooting at Palestinian youths, tanks in the narrow streets of Palestinian refugee camps, checkpoints and fanatic settlers, much more than that it shows fanatic Palestinians shouting 'death to Israel, kill the Jews', smuggling weapons, training exercises of the new Hamas executive force etc. Someone active in the Dutch socialist party and no friend of Israel, closely followed the news on German TV during the Lebanon war and said it was quite favorable to Lebanon/Hezbollah.

      It might also be due to an aversion of many Germans to militarism and nationalism as a reaction to their country's Nazi history, like Leonie Schultens suggests, although it is a bit strange at least that they are apparently not so upset about militarism of other states. One cannot escape the observation that Germans (and other Europeans) have a problem with militaristic and aggressive Jews especially. Chinese, Russians and all kinds of African tribes may kill their enemies in brutal ways and silence their opponents brutally, Jews should not do that. They ought to be civilized. They ought to not do to others what was done to them. After all, Jews know how it feels to be persecuted, beaten and chased away.

      Germans equating Israeli behavior in the territories to the Nazis, also known as Holocaust Inversion, is not only disgusting, but also frightening. It is in fact a form of anti-Semitism no less than Holocaust denial, directed both towards the Jewish community in general and specifically to Israel. It is attractive for Germans to find a way out of their horrible past, an escape, without actually denying what happened. Holocaust inversion makes it possible to relieve their guilt and to view Germans as a normal people, like every other people capable of doing great things but also of doing terrible things, and not even worse than the very people they tried to exterminate. After all, we all harbor good and evil inside us. As Manfred Gerstenfield notes, politicians of mainstream parties use the Nazi analogy:

      Using Nazi genocidal language for Israel's actions is another tool of Holocaust inversion. The most effective way to sanitize Germany's immense crimes is to accuse Israel of acting similarly. In 2002 Norbert Blüm, a former German Christian Democrat minister of labor, charged that the Jewish state was conducting a "Vernichtungskrieg" against the Palestinians-the Nazi expression for a war of extermination.

      Of course no people is inherently good or evil. But that should not lead us away from the facts, or make us invent or deny facts or suggest similarities where none exist.

      Not just Germans, but many people in Europe think that the Jews have been transformed from an oppressed people in an oppressing people, and many people say that especially Jews should not do such things to other people. On one hand, this is an understandable position. But it is also discriminatory at best, and anti-Semitic at worst. It says essentially that Jews are to be held to higher standards of behavior because they were persecuted throughout history, and this is being said to them by the very people who persecuted them. "We murdered you, but we learned from our past, paid you reparations, and now you should act conform our new standards".
      Very moral indeed.

      Not only many Germans said "nie wieder" (never again) after the war, many Jews did so too. They decided that there is only one way to ensure this, and that is by being able to defend themselves in their own state. This is not to say that Israel was created because of the Holocaust, as the first Zionists came to Palestine in the 19th century, and in the years before the war the Jewish community in Palestine was essentially functioning as an independent state, minding its own affairs in many respects. Unfortunately they had no say in Jewish immigration to Palestine and could not prevent the British authorities from closing the country almost entirely for Jewish immigration in 1939, under strong pressure from the Arabs. They had to passively look on as reports came in about what happened to the Jews in Europe, although illegal immigration rescued some 60.000 people.

      Israel was founded on the premise that the problem of anti-Semitism could not be solved within Europe or other countries where Jews had lived for centuries, but only by Jews taking their fate into their own hands, by creating a national home for the Jewish people. This ideology, Zionism, was not a result of the Holocaust, but the Holocaust proved it right in the most cynical way.

      Jews working the land and defending themselves was quite new and disturbing to some people. Jews shooting at and oppressing another people even more. Yet that doesn't justify the allegation that the Jews 'overreacted' and went from one extreme to the other, turned from helpless victims into cruel perpetrators. The occupation was justified in light of the Arab aggression and rejectionism, but the settlement project has been a grave mistake. The 'wall' and the checkpoints are a result of the second Intifada, in which about 1000 Israelis were killed, mostly civilians. Soldiers and settlers sometimes behave cruelly (and are convicted for that in some - too few - cases), like American soldiers and French soldiers and every other army does in time of war. This is no justification, and every army has the duty to abide by the rules of war and every state has the duty to punish those who don't, but it's not fair to be particularly upset if Jews are doing such things, and it is disgusting to compare them to the people who tried to exterminate them and built a huge destruction infrastructure to accomplish that.

      Jews have lost the innocence we attributed to them in the past, when they were accused of many evils like the plague, financial breakdowns or wars, but they haven't become the equivalent of their murderers. By gaining political independence they have become more like a 'normal' people, with its heroic and noble deeds but also with its indifference and sometimes cruelty towards its enemies. It is time the outside world starts looking at them and treating them like a normal people, and doesn't expect them to be more moral than their enemies or compare them to their former persecutors.

      Ratna Pelle

      Original content is Copyright by the author 2007. Posted at ZioNation-Zionism and Israel Web Log, http://www.zionism-israel.com/log/archives/00000365.html where your intelligent and constructive comments are welcome. Disributed by ZNN list. Subscribe by sending a message to ZNN-subscribe@yahoogroups.com. Please forward by e-mail with this notice, cite this article and link to it. Other uses by permission only.

      If you like this post – click to Reddit!

      add to del.icio.us

      Add to digg - digg it

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.