19177Re: Disposable email not going to designated folder
- May 29, 2010The reason is that the recipient filters only look at the To/Cc headers. Spam and other messages sent to you by Bcc (where your address is *not* listed in the To or Cc header) will not be caught by these filters. It's an old gripe .
In other words the filters are not a real substitute for the DEA feature's previous ability to specify which folder to deliver messages to (which worked 100% of the time, even for messages received by Bcc).
At least messages fetched from external POP3 accounts still have the option to specify the delivery folder...
See also this thread on emaildiscussions.com.
--- In Y-Mail@yahoogroups.com, "h.hans" <hans11@...> wrote:
> Hmm, I tried to reply to another post on this topic (post number 19134, "ALERT: Yahoo! Mail Plus subscribers - Yahoo! Disposable Email Addres"), and it said the message was posted, but it does not appear. Perhaps there is a long delay for moderator review?
> You may be interested to know that, even if you set up the filters the way Yahoo now says, it still won't do 100% accurate folder delivery as it did in the past. Now, even with the correct filters, most, if not all, spam, as well as legitimate mail (such as those marked "undisclosed recipients"), will wind up in your Inbox (contrary to their promotional claims). This is because they changed the mechanism to some kind of "fuzzy logic", apparently. I reported this to Yahoo Customer Care and they declined to pursue this as an issue. For further details, see my article "Did Yahoo break Disposable Email Addresses" on Usenet and Cnet.
> In the above-mentioned reply that did not appear, I mentioned that maybe this is Yahoo's way of trying to "end of life" Mail Plus and migrate users off of it. I was sort of half-joking, but reading the comment below about click-throughs makes me wonder.
> A variety of additional issues with the recent changes to AddressGuard were posted on Yahoo Buzz (see the user comments below the article):
> --- In Y-Mail@yahoogroups.com, G Pollara gpollara@ wrote:
> > Gerry, whilst I don't have this issue you have with redirecting disposable email addresses, your point in principle is correct. When one pays a fee, you expect something in return. Other than the disposable email addresses and no adverts, there seem few benefits left to a Plus account now. Presumably Yahoo makes more money on click through advertising on non-paid accounts than the Plus ones. If not, then this is not a good customer retention scheme. If you're not paying for something regularly, it makes it that much easier to move to a rival service.
> > ________________________________
> > From: Gerry sp1d3rc1d3r-ymug@
> > To: Y-Mail@yahoogroups.com
> > Sent: Fri, 21 May, 2010 6:00:07
> > Subject: [Y-Mail] Re: Disposable email not going to designated folder
> > Disposable Email Addresses are what kept me with Yahoo too. I se no reason to pay for the 'Plus' account any more as there is no longer a 'Plus'. I have hundreds of disposable emails addresses and was already using a lot of my filter quota... So I have don;t have enough filter available to accomplish the task. You would think that if they were going to do this they would have upped the max on filters.
> > Even with unlimited filters... defining them all again would be a big task. Afer 11 years with Yahoo they have finally managed to run off this paying customer. I know... I know... don't let the door hit ya... :-)
> > --- In Y-Mail@yahoogroups.com, "lloyd" <lmhaskins@> wrote:
> > >
> > > [Before I start, the latest message that I can see on this board is from
> > > May 3, 2010 5:35 pm; what's up with no messages for 15 days?]
> > >
> > > Today (5/18/2010), I noticed that email going to my disposable addresses
> > > is going to my Inbox instead of the specified folders. When I went to
> > > look at the settings for a couple of my addresses, I noticed a new
> > > interface for disposable addresses in that it's no longer in the
> > > old-style Options page but now has a new page under the "new" email
> > > settings. It only now lets me modify the address keyword (what comes
> > > after basename-), optional color indicator, the "From" name for that
> > > address, and any notes. There is no longer an option to specify the
> > > destination folder, plus I can no longer say whether email to this
> > > address should be filtered or possibly sent to the Spam folder.
> > >
> > > In place of being able to specify the destination folder, there is a
> > > general link for managing filters, even though it says "...for
> > > disposable addresses."
> > >
> > > What this means is that I now have to go through all of my disposable
> > > addresses--I have 187--and set destination folders for each manually.
> > > Plus I have to reorder the new ones since I have very general filters at
> > > the end of the list to sweep up emails that made it through the earlier
> > > filters.
> > >
> > > Disposable addresses are what keeps me from going to Gmail. Being able
> > > to easily specify folders was part of that.
> > >
> > > Bad move, Yahoo Mail!
> > >
> > > Lloyd
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>