1812 Re: ? on sailor clothes
- --- In WarOf1812@yahoogroups.com, Peter Catley <peter.catley@...>
> Agreed, that is the point I make, it is a matter of WHERE you draw
> line of compromise because we all do.is
> I find it depressing when people criticise others for deciding
> differently from themselves, one persons conscientious re-enactor
> another's farbie:-)P**,
> Authenticity is good and to be encouraged but failure to achieve
> should not be denigrated.
Though I understand your point, I will argue that in more cases
than I think a lot of folks admit, the opposite is just as true.
In AWI there is a movement on above and beyond the "Progressive"
mindset, and we are calling it "Immersion". Much the same as when
I did ACW oodles of years ago and we were called "hardcores".
There is just as much scorn from the mainstream community that we
are harmful to their fun filled family outing weekends because we
want it as real as possible.
I believe that if a person is recreating a mythological character
for a Dungoens and Dragons convention, or going to a Rennaissance
Faire...then their impressions can take on whatever absurdity they
wish. But, in our business, we are portraying actual parts of
history, and trying to recreate that life and appearance as best as
possible, not only for ourselves but the public that comes to see us
who are trying to get a feel for what these predecessors looked
like. There is a higher purpose here in my mind.
As you say, no one should be ridiculed but on the same note, there
are many folks ( in many timeperiods) that get a basic, cheap, quasi-
authentic impression and thats as far as they go. It's a never
ending debate and one that will haunt this hobby forever and add
fuel to the fire to those in the modern community that think we're
just a bunch of idiot adolecents running about playing war. The
more honest and serious we take ourselves in recreating quality
history with quality historical impressions the less they can
belittle what we endevour to accomplish.
> On 25 Jul 2008, at 02:29, bolton1812 wrote:
> > --- In WarOf1812@yahoogroups.com, Peter Catley <peter.catley@>
> > wrote:
> > >
> > > Bob,
> > >
> > > In addition as re-enactors we are frequently too fat, too old
> > fatrefer
> > > too healthy, just think teeth!
> > >
> > > In the Royal Navy even today there are periods the sailors
> > to asfor
> > > make and mend time :-)
> > >
> > > Cheers
> > >
> > > P**
> > ...agreed...but very few are willing to make a total life change
> > their impressions...that's why getting at least the clothing and
> > gear dead on can do a world of good.
> > Cheers,
> > Bob
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]