RE: [Unity_Games] Settler's Variant [was Danger Planet SR]
- Oddly enough, I agree with Dave on everything he said. I too own the 6
player expansion but have not played it.
The once-around variant appears to just make the game last longer but
doesn't add anything to the satisfaction of playing it. Since Settlers
relies so much on the role of the dice anyway, the shorter it is the better,
for the unlucky.
For another variant, lots of people play the Java version online with a "no
trading" policy, which makes it interesting because you really have to
spread yourself out and ports become a strategic focul point rather than an
afterthought. And another variant is the "two trade" variant where the
active player is allowed to make two trade offers only. Shortens the game
From: Dave Bernazzani [mailto:dber@...]
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2001 11:27 AM
Subject: [Unity_Games] Settler's Variant [was Danger Planet SR]
> We finished with Settlers of Catan with 4 players. A very close game.I've not seen or played that way. I always enjoy Basic Settlers (3 or 4P)
> I think the final score was 10, 9, 9, 8. I had 9. We played with an
> interesting variant that I had not seen before. In order to win, you
> had to hold your 10 points for a full round of turns. So the other
> players had 1 round to try and steal away longest road or largest
> army. I didn't think much of it when it was explained, but we ended
> up using this rule. One player got to ten and then we all pooled
> our resources and stole longest road away from him. He eventually
> won by building another city and settlement. I'm not sure the rule adds
> much and just lengthens the game. (ours took 2 hours).
> Has anyone else seen this variant or have any opinions
> about it.
but the last few games have always seemed to finish a short bit after I
would prefer they finished (maybe 5 or 10 minutes too long?) so I'm unlikely
to try anything that might lengthen the game. This has been the main reason
I've avoided 6P settlers with the expansions (which I own but have not
played) as those 5-6P games I've observed at the SSG (and elsewhere) seem to
run on a bit too long for my tastes.
But I can see where some would like this rule - gives the others an
opportunity to react after someone reaches the 10 point mark.
http://www.gis.net/~dber <http://www.gis.net/~dber> (South Shore Gamers)
Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
Unity Games webpage: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Unity_Games
To unsubscribe send email to Unity_Gamesemail@example.com
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service