Faith Journey of Judith J. WestLee
- CALLED OUT INFORMATION SERVICE
This story is shared with Judy WestLee's permission.
Faith Journey of Judith J. WestLee
I was raised on a farm in southeast Minnesota. I was baptized and
confirmed as a Missouri Lutheran.
The little white frame church in my home village was an important place in
my childhood. There we received the annual �the Jews killed Jesus� sermon
and the annual �the Catholics are going to hell and so is everyone else who
is not Missouri Lutheran� sermon. Every Sunday the liturgy consisted of our
minister yelling out his part of liturgy and the congregation responding as
quickly as we possibly could. I remember turning to my mother one Sunday
and asking, �What did we do wrong?� because I was assuming we had said
something wrong in our part of the liturgy.
With this understanding of �church� and �God,� I stopped attending church
as soon as I left home for college at age 17. However, while I attending
college I started to explore other ways of �doing church.� I attended
several denominations� services new to me by tagging along with friends.
A move to another state and city marked the end of my church attendance �
to any church. I was in what I termed my �agnostic humanist� period. And
this period would last for several years.
Then I made friends with two women who didn�t know each other, but who were
both United Methodists. I liked what I heard about their concern with
others and non-judgmentalism. I started taking downhill skiing with one of
these friends. Even while traveling around the area and dressed in our ski
clothes, she insisted upon attending church services on Sunday mornings.
So, what could I do but tag along again?
After 2-3 years of this practice, I started attending the local United
Methodist church all by myself! This was a momentous event for me! By this
time I was in my early 30�s. I clearly remember sitting in the pew hearing
for the first time that God loved me �warts and all.� I didn�t have to
perfect in order for God to love me. I heard for the first time that God
was friendly and loving rather than angry and vengeful. I sat quietly in
the pew with tears running down my cheeks! I couldn't believe how happy I
I joined that little United Methodist Church and accepted positions on the
local council. Soon after that I celebrated my newly found sobriety.
Sunday morning I sat upstairs in the pew. Thursday evening I sat around the
tables in the basement in a 12 Step meeting.
This was a very happy time in my life. Then tragedy struck. My
sister-in-law, whom I loved very much, was involved in a very serious car
accident. She lived, but was severely brain damaged. I spent days the
hospital with my brother and niece as we waited to learn if she would return
In the midst of that, I drove home, completely drained of energy. As I
drove, I argued with God and railed at God for allowing this terrible
accident to happen. I asked why wasn�t it ME in that accident rather than
my sister-in-law. I was single and no one would notice that I was gone. My
sister-in-law had her husband and child.
After about 30 minutes of that, I was at the last turn on the highway
before arriving home. I became quiet for a couple of minutes and then I
prayed: �God, I don�t understand this at all. But Your will be done. For
whatever it is worth, You have my life. All of it. Do with it as You
Well! That was the most dangerous prayer I have ever prayed! Shortly
after that, I started feeling God�s �call� for me to go into ministry. I
shrugged it off. I ignored it. I laughed at myself about it. But it
wouldn�t go away. I came into a fairly large amount of unexpected money.
I again was in my car pondering how I should use the money: buy a mobile
home or town house? Start a retirement fund? Once again, I was finally
quiet for a moment. And I clearly heard a voice say firmly: �You will use
the money to attend seminary.� I almost drove the car into the ditch on
That night I never even went to bed. Instead I prayed and paced my
apartment. I prayed while studying the stars from my balcony. I asked if
this was really what God wanted me to do. By dawn I was quiet, full of
energy and I had my answer. I would go to seminary.
I graduated from seminary and was appointed to a rural parish. Again, I
was very happy. But a few months after coming into parish ministry God
revealed to me the true nature of my sexual identity. I finally
acknowledged what I never before could face: that I am a lesbian.
At the time I wasn�t even certain what the word �lesbian� meant. I had to
ask someone for a definition of �dyke� [which I was called] because I had no
idea what it meant. I couldn�t justify this new sexual identity with my
understanding of the Bible and Christianity. I read with pain the new
negative pronouncements from the United Methodist General Conferences. I
hated myself and wondered how I could have failed so completely. I became
Luckily, I was able to find a friendly counseling place in the Twin
Cities. I went into 1-to-1 counseling. I joined a sexual identity
exploration small group. Later I joined a lesbian support group. I
found a new community of lesbians. My new support group kept me alive
and prevented my suicide.
I continued to serve in ministry as a local parish pastor. But as time
went on, it felt as if my two worlds: the church and the lesbian community
were spreading further and further apart. Finally, I could stand the
pressure no longer. I �came out� [told my sexual identity] to my district
superintendent and subsequently went on honorable location.
The call to ministry would not stop, however. After a couple of years I
asked my new district superintendent to again be appointed to a local
parish. I wanted to walk with God�s people again as their pastor. In order
to comply with the United Methodist Book of Discipline, I took a personal
vow with my bishop to live in celibacy.
I told her that if I found I could no longer do that, I would tell her so.
I went back into the parish ministry. A year later I met the most
remarkable person I have ever met. We fell in love. I made an
appointment to tell my bishop that this had happened and that we planned to
have a Holy Union ceremony. It was agreed that I would go on Leave of
That was five years ago. I still cry as I miss being in parish ministry.
My partner and I are active in a local United Methodist Church where we feel
comfortable and accepted. I have become active on the National Affirmation
Council, a caucus which speaks for gay/lesbian/bisexual/transgendered United
Methodists. I have found employment, but continually miss ministry.
Through all of this, I feel the close presence of God standing with me.
Where will this end? Only God knows. And I will trust God to make the
wisest choice for my life as I have done ever since that prayer for God to
take my life. I have never taken it back into my hands.
Judy WestLee is co-convener of Affirmation: United Methodists for Lesbian,
Gay, Bisexual, and Transgendered Concerns
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com