Christians v. Gays: The Damage Done
By David Gushee
Dr. David P. Gushee, a Christian ethicist, teacher, activist, and churchman, serves as Distinguished University Professor of Christian Ethics and Director of the Center for Theology and Public Life at Mercer University.
Predictably, conservative Christian activists and commentators are already decrying the Supreme Court’s decisions today rejecting the constitutionality of the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act and permitting same-sex marriages to resume in California.
Gay, Evangelical and Seeking Acceptance in Church
by Rachel Zoll
Sunday Jun 30, 2013
Evangelicals are being challenged to change their views of gays and lesbians, and the pressure isn’t coming from the gay rights movement or watershed court rulings: Once silent for fear of being shunned, more gay and lesbian evangelicals are speaking out about how they’ve struggled to reconcile their beliefs and sexual orientation.
June 28, 2013 1:31PM
Message to Anti-Gay Pastors: Double Down
Post by Candace Chellew-Hodge
Double down and be very afraid. That was the message to pastors during a conference call today by an attorney from the Alliance Defending Freedom, the right-wing outfit of attorneys that represented Protect Marriage at the U.S. Supreme Court over California's Proposition 8.
The conference call, held by Pulpit Freedom Sunday, a program created by Jim Garlow's Skyline Wesleyan Church in La Mesa, Calif., featured ADF attorney Joe La Rue outlining the impact of the Supreme Court's decision overturning Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act and returning the Prop 8 case to California.
[Called Out Editors’ Note – In the “straw men” picture that accompanies the article, the figures appear to be made out of a combination of hay (round bales) and straw (rectangular bales.) We’ll leave it to you to look up the difference between hay and straw.]
An Evangelical Intellectual Takes On Same-Sex Marriage, Grasps at Straw Men
Following Christian philosopher William Lane Craig through a corn maze
Eric C. Miller is a lecturer in the Department of Communication Arts and Sciences at the Pennsylvania State University. His research focuses on the rhetoric of the religious right.
Of all the terms used to describe the recent shift in public opinion toward same-sex marriage, “seismic” is one of the most common. Given the centrality of California to this discussion, headline writers have found “Seismic Shift” difficult to resist. And it makes sense—the earth seems to have moved, structures shifted or collapsed.
In recent weeks the metaphor has found fresh resonance. Opponents of same-sex marriage are frantically rushing to raise and brace their beams.
LGBT Group Finds Acceptance at Evangelical College
by Sarah Parvini
Saturday Jul 13, 2013
PASADENA, Calif. -- Nick Palacios struggled to get his conservative Pentecostal parents to accept him as a gay evangelical Christian for nearly a decade before his family found a common ground through faith.
Now, as an openly gay seminarian, the 29-year-old hopes to carve out a similar acceptance for other gays in the broader evangelical community through his role as president of the nation’s first LGBT student club sanctioned by a major evangelical seminary. The group, called OneTable, formed last fall at Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, one of the world’s largest multi-denominational seminaries, and has attracted about three dozen students.
Dean of Chichester: Being gay is ‘not a choice but a given’
Update: An original draft of this article published on 13 July included a misquotation which made it appear as though the Dean of Chichester suggested that being gay is a choice. The talk held at Chichester Cathedral titled ‘Gay Marriage- Sacrament or Scandal’, included an impassioned debate during which the Dean stood up for gay rights and equal marriage and said he was “horrified” by homophobic behaviour. The correct quote from the Dean read that being gay is “not a choice but a given”.
The Dean of Chichcester held a public talk at Chichester Cathedral last week, which focussed on equal marriage, during which he reflected on the idea that “homosexuality is not a choice but a given”, but also that there was no easy solution to religious opposition to equal marriage.
July 19, 2013 6:33PM
FRC's Perkins Selling Straight Hot Sex
Post by Candace Chellew-Hodge
Faced with a growing acceptance of gay and lesbian people in both society and the church, the religious right is rolling out its new sales pitch for heterosexuality: "Married heterosexuals have the best sex!"
After failing to sell the younger generation on the intrinsic value of marriage as the best way to raise children, they've decided to back up a few steps and instead pitch the great baby-making sex that straight married couples apparently have.
"Those who worship God weekly have the best sex," asserted Patrick F. Fagan, Senior Fellow and Director of the Marriage and Religion Research Institute (MARRI) at the Family Research Council.
Archbishop Desmond Tutu: I would rather go to Hell than worship a homophobic�God
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, famous for his role in ending�Apartheid, has said that he would rather go to Hell if he discovered that God was homophobic.
Pope Says He Won�t Judge Gay Priests
by Nicole Winfield
Monday Jul 29, 2013
Pope Francis reached out to gays on Monday, saying he wouldn�t judge priests for their sexual orientation in a remarkably open and wide-ranging news conference as he returned from his first foreign trip.
"If someone is gay and he searches for the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge?" Francis asked.
Archbishop of Canterbury: �Popular opinion on equal marriage is not a case for changing obedience to�God�
Speaking at a Christian conference, the Archbishop of Canterbury has said that popular opinion on equal marriage is �not a case for changing obedience to God�.
Pope Francis: Who am I to judge gay�people?
In a significant development Pope Francis has said that gay people should not be judged or marginalised and should be integrated into society.
July 29, 2013
Will Francis� Statements on Women and Gays �Make a Mess� Inside the Church?
By Mary E. Hunt
Mary E. Hunt, Ph.D., is a feminist theologian who is co-founder and co-director of the Women's Alliance for Theology, Ethics and Ritual (WATER) in Silver Spring, Maryland, USA. A Roman Catholic active in the women-church movement, she lectures and writes on theology and ethics with particular attention to liberation issues.
Pope Francis made his first foray abroad since becoming pope and by all accounts his stock is up. In the case of World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro, however, the encore will be more important than the performance itself. Will his comments on the plane ride home regarding the role of women and��the�gay lobby� translate into changes inside the institutional church? One can only hope, though it remains too early to tell.�
I wasn�t there, but I watched enough live coverage to get a feel for the scene at Copacabana Beach. Whether I wanted it or not, I probably earned the plenary indulgence promised to his Twitter followers! These Vatican people think of everything from age to age.�
[Called Out Editors� Note:� We thought this was interesting and needed to go in both the Religion and Marriage posts.� We�ve known about this book almost since it was published.� One of us has a friend that does go on about this book.]
Christian church performed same-sex marriages almost 2,000 years�ago
A book by historian John Boswell around the origins of equal marriage is being released in digital edition for the first time in August, and discusses that almost 2,000 years ago, the Christian church performed same-sex weddings.
July 30, 2013 3:45PM
U.S. [Catholic] Bishops Have No Trouble Judging Gays
Post by Peter Montgomery
Pope Francis�s informal comments about gay people � �Who am I to judge them if they�re seeking the Lord in good faith?� � have drawn a lot of attention, including a valuable context-providing analysis�from Mary Hunt here on RD.
The remarks stood out because their gracious tone toward gay people is a striking departure from the rhetoric of this pope�s immediate predecessor -- so striking, in fact, that Thomas Reese, a priest and former editor of the Jesuit-published America magazine, wrote, "The pope made it clear that there is no room for homophobia either in the church or society. But if I had said what he said 24 hours before he said it, I would have been reported to the archbishop."
Analysis: Pope�s Revolution; Not All are Pleased
by Nicole Winfield
Wednesday Jul 31, 2013
The Francis Revolution is underway. Not everyone is pleased.
Four months into his papacy, Francis has called on young Catholics in the trenches to take up spiritual arms to shake up a dusty, doctrinaire church that is losing faithful and relevance. He has said women must have a greater role - not as priests, but a place in the church that recognizes that Mary is more important than any of the apostles. And he has turned the Vatican upside down, quite possibly knocking the wind out of a poisonously homophobic culture by merely uttering the word "gay" and saying: so what?
Pope�s Comments Push LGBTQ Equality Issues Forward
by David �Perry
Thursday Aug 1, 2013
Pope Francis stunned Catholics and several other denominations when he declared, "If a person is gay and seeks the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge that person?"
The Pontiff, speaking in Italian, was fielding questions from reporters during his return to Rome after a successful tour in Brazil when the question of gays in the priesthood, and the rumor of the "gay lobby" that supposedly forced his predecessor Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI into retirement.
[Called Out Editors� Note:� We include this only to demonstrate the level of invective some so-called religious leaders will stoop to.]
Anti-gay evangelist accuses US Supreme Court judge of being a��homosexualist�
An anti-gay evangelist has written a column which accuses one of the US Supreme Court justices of being a �homosexualist� for ruling in favour of �gay rights in the past.
Archbishop of Detroit: Pope�s comments on gay people represent �no�change�
The Archbishop of Detroit has spoken out over excitement about Pope Francis� seemingly progressive comments on homosexuality, arguing that the pontiff �didn�t say anything different� to established Catholic teaching.
Openly gay minister ordained in Minneapolis
9:26 PM, Aug 25, 2013
MINNEAPOLIS - A church in Minneapolis made history on Saturday by ordaining an openly gay minister for the first time.
Daniel Vigilante is now the minister of outreach at Trinity Community Church at 28th and Humboldt Avenue.
Church sign goes viral: ‘Jesus had two dads and he turned out just fine’
The picture of the sign was viewed over a million times after it was posted on Reddit
An inclusive church in Canada has joined others using its sign to advertise a message of inclusion, and has found viral internet fame as a result.
The St John’s Anglican Church, erected the sign saying: “Jesus had two dads, and he turned out just fine!”.
Comment: Canada is embracing gay Muslims
Journalist Barry Dennison explores how a group of gay Muslims practice their faith during Ramadan in Canada.
After seeing numerous internet pictures of gay men being hung by the neck in Iran, it raised questions: How is Islam practiced in western society? Does the Canadian Government truly give everyone equal opportunity to believe as they choose?
Editors’ Note: The Religion Dispatches items by Peter Montgomery are weekly summaries of religious news affecting LGBTQ people.
Pray the Gay Away :: An In-Depth Look at 'Conversion Therapy'
by Christiana Lilly
Just three days after Christmas in 2014, Leelah Alcorn wrote a final message on her Tumblr account -- a suicide note.
"Either I live the rest of my life as a lonely man who wishes he were a woman or I live my life as a lonelier woman who hates herself. There's no winning. There's no way out," she wrote. "People say 'it gets better' but that isn't true in my case. It gets worse. Each day I get worse."
By Peter Montgomery October 12, 2015
Catholic philosopher claims gay people are ‘inherently disordered’
Roberto Marchesini also claims gay people do not mature past childhood.
As the Catholic Church continue to question their views on homosexuality, a renowned Italian philosopher has spoken out in support of those who wish to keep gays away from the religion.
By Peter Montgomery October 18, 2015
Let There Be Light: Handwritten Draft of King James Bible Reveals Secrets of Its Creation
By Ed Simon October 19, 2015
The King James Bible may well be the greatest work of literature ever written by committee—and now we know a bit more about the collaboration that produced it.
Jeffrey Allen Miller, an English professor at Montclair State University conducting research at Cambridge announced a remarkable discovery last week: “in the archives of Sidney Sussex College there survives now the earliest known draft of any part of the King James Bible, unmistakably in the hand of one of the King James translators.”
The Untold Story of Religious Support for Gay Rights
By Rebecca Alpert October 22, 2015
Now that we have marriage equality, and the Pope is hugging gay friends, what more is there to say about the gay community and religion?
Quite a bit, if you ask Heather White, author of Reforming Sodom: Protestants and the Rise of Gay Rights. And the conversation should start with a re-interpretation of recent history.
By Peter Montgomery October 23, 2015
Religious Leaders Pledge to Protect Religious Freedom—For Everyone
By Sarah Posner October 26, 2015
Twenty-one religious leaders of various faiths gathered on the steps of the National Cathedral on Friday to sign a pledge for religious freedom and to call on public officials and political candidates to reject bigotry and protect religious freedom. http://religiondispatches.org/religious-leaders-pledge-to-protect-religious-freedom-for-everyone/?utm_source=Religion+Dispatches+Newsletter&utm_campaign=78d8b826af-RD_Daily_Newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_742d86f519-78d8b826af-42408065
Gay priest tells Pope: Your church is making life hell for gay people
A Vatican priest who was sacked after coming out for gay has shared the message he sent challenging the Pope on LGBT rights.
By Peter Montgomery November 1, 2015
Gay Priest Fired by Vatican Describes 'Special Homophobia'
by Hermann Munoz and Alan Clendenning
Thursday Nov 5, 2015
BARCELONA, Spain -- The Polish monsignor who came out as gay and was fired by the Vatican just before a meeting of bishops about outreach to gays, divorcees and more traditional Catholic families says that a "special kind of homophobia" exists among priests, because those who are homosexual are forced to hate themselves.
Religious Americans Keeping the Faith, But Changing with Time
by Rachel Zoll
Tuesday Nov 3, 2015
A survey released Tuesday brought some good news for faith leaders alarmed by the spike in the number of Americans who say they have no ties to a particular religion.
Haters Gonna Hate: Christians Aren't Buying Wal-Mart's High Score on AFA Copy Cat Index
Tuesday Nov 3, 2015
The anti-gay religious right has never been known for its originality. So, it comes as no surprise that the anti-gay hate group American Family Association has ripped off the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) to create their own version of the gay rights group's Corporate Equality Index.
The Problem with Pew’s Science & Religion Poll
By Andrew Aghapour and Michael Schulson November 5, 2015
To get good answers, you have to ask good questions.
“Generally, do you think science and religion are often in conflict?” is not a very helpful question. It’s vague from start to finish. Religion could refer to the beliefs and practices of evangelical Protestants, Jesuits, secular Jews, or Theravada Buddhists—or even some imagined mashup of all global faiths. Science is fuzzy, too. It refers to a wide range of disciplines (e.g. astronomy, botany, psychiatry) and occurs in a variety of settings (laboratories, forests, high school auditoriums). In the popular imagination, it’s practiced by everyone from white-coated nerds to egomaniacal monsters.
By Peter Montgomery November 7, 2015
Will SCOTUS Call the “Bluff” of Religious Liberty Activists?
By Kara Loewentheil November 9, 2015
If the announcement that the Supreme Court will hear arguments in a challenge to the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive coverage requirement (CCR) makes you feel like you’re experiencing deja vu, you’re not exactly wrong.
After Hobby Lobby, the Administration took a slow and leisurely approach to creating new regulations for the accommodation process. Finally released in July, the regulations, among other things, instituted a process for those non-profit religious organizations (NPRO) that objected to the original accommodation.
Out of Options: Christians’ Losing Battle Over Equality
By Kaya Oakes November 11, 2015
In the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to make marriage equality the law, conservative Christian thinkers have followed two tracks. On the one hand, writers like Rod Dreher and Ross Douthat have used the language of war, battle, and struggle as a call to retrenchment. If we just went back to what the Bible intended for marriage and sexuality, in their thinking, Christianity might be able to steer itself back toward a central place in American culture and morality.
However, most conservative Christian thinkers are also aware that if this is a battle, it’s a losing one. And in fact, it has probably already been lost.
By Peter Montgomery November 12, 2015
Mormons Announce No Baptisms for Babies with Gay Parents
Friday Nov 6, 2015
It's been a banner year for gay rights with the Mormon church -- until yesterday.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints announced a new policy Thursday that denies baptism to children living in a same-sex household. In a separate announcement, the church told leaders that participating in a same-sex marriage is tantamount to apostasy, or abandoning their faith,KUTV reports.
LGBT Activists Upset Over New Mormon Church Baptism Rule
by Brady McCombs
Friday Nov 6, 2015
Gay and lesbian Mormons and their supporters are reeling over a rule change by church officials that says members in same-sex marriages can be kicked out, and bars their children from being baptized unless they disavow same-sex relationships.
Protest of Mormon LGBT Policy Planned in Salt Lake City
by Brady McCombs
Monday Nov 16, 2015
A day after the Mormon church stood behind its new rules targeting gay members and their children, while issuing clarifications, several hundred people are expected at a rally in Salt Lake City to protest their displeasure with the policy changes.