Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

House Passes Bill Allowing Discrimination

Expand Messages
  • umcornet
    From the Associated Baptist Press House passes bill allowing discrimination as Bush reaffirms faith-based plan By Robert Marus March 4, 2005 WASHINGTON (ABP)
    Message 1 of 1 , Mar 4, 2005
      From the Associated Baptist Press

      House passes bill allowing discrimination as Bush reaffirms
      faith-based plan
      By Robert Marus
      March 4, 2005

      WASHINGTON (ABP) -- The House of Representatives has passed another
      bill giving religious charities the right to discriminate in hiring,
      even when they receive federal funds.

      On a largely party-line vote of 224 to 200, the chamber passed the Job
      Training Improvement Act March 2. The legislation is a reauthorization
      and extension of a federal job-training program that has been around
      since 1982. It funds local organizations that help provide unemployed
      people with marketable job skills.

      The program's original authorizing legislation barred organizations
      receiving grants under it from discriminating on the basis of
      religion, race, gender and other categories. The new bill deletes
      those protections only for religious providers, and only on the basis
      of religion.

      The 1964 Civil

      Rights Act already allows churches and synagogues to discriminate in
      hiring for most positions on the basis of religious principles.
      However, the courts have not definitively settled the issue of whether
      religious groups retain that right when hiring for a position wholly
      or partly funded by tax dollars.

      "The bill turns back the clock on decades of civil rights protections
      in our job training programs. This is simply wrong," said Rep. Dale
      Kildee (D-Mich.), debating the measure on the House floor.

      But the bill's supporters said churches and other religious
      job-training agencies would be unable to maintain fidelity to their
      mission if not given the right to hire workers on a religious basis --
      even when using tax dollars.

      "Our nation's faith-based institutions have a proven track record in
      meeting the training and counseling needs of our citizens," said Rep.
      John Boehner (R-Ohio). "Why would we want to deny them the opportunity
      to help in federal job-training efforts?"

      Rep. Bobby Scott (D-Va.) offered an amendment that would have restored
      the bill's original 1982 language barring grant recipients from
      discriminating on the basis of religion. It failed on a 239-186 vote.
      Fourteen of his fellow Democrats crossed the aisle to vote against
      Scott's amendment, while only three Republicans supported it.

      The vote came just a day after President Bush spoke strongly of such
      provisions as essential to his plan to fund more social services
      through churches and other religious organizations.

      "I want this issue resolved," Mr. Bush said, in a speech to about 250
      religious leaders invited to a White House conference on the
      faith-based plan. "Congress needs to send me the same language
      protecting religious hiring [rights] that President Clinton signed on
      four other occasions. And they need to do it this year. And if we
      can't get it done this year, I'll consider measures that can be taken
      through executive action."

      Bush was referring to several other federal social-service programs
      containing similar religious-hiring provisions that Congress passed
      and Clinton signed into law between 1996 and 2000. However, Clinton's
      administration made it their policy not to give grants directly to
      churches and other pervasively religious providers, thus rendering the
      hiring provisions moot.

      Bush, however, has aggressively pushed a comprehensive plan to fund
      social services through houses of worship. Although the effort as a
      whole failed in Congress, Bush has slowly implemented parts of the
      plan via executive orders and other administrative actions.

      Bush's allies in the House have also attempted piecemeal
      implementation of the plan in various bills, such as the Job Training
      Improvement Act, authorizing individual grant programs. The House
      passed a similar version of the bill in 2003, but could not agree with
      the Senate on it.

      The bill is H.R. 27. It now goes to the Senate, where it will likely
      face stiff opposition.

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.