RE: [TolkienDiscussions] Re: The Hobbit - Chapter Thirteen Summary [SPOILERS for the Silmarillion]
- <<I think Tolkien wanted the Silmarils to become a part of the realms
to, in a way, hallow them or imbue them with a quality of the hidden
realm of Aman.
...Ultimately he wanted them to be removed from the reach
of Elves and Men and to become a part of the fabric of Arda.>>
I agree completely.
- Jack <jack@...> wrote:Servo Kamen said: There are some who think that the Arkenstone might be one of the lost SilmarilsThat occurred to me when I read that .***spoiler alert****.one of the elven lords (Maedhros was it?) threw his Silmaril into a crack in the earth.But I dont think it can be Smaugs cavern was dark. A silmaril would have lit it up:o)
Jack...Maybe so. It's just a theory I've seen go around.
SHADOWKamen. GIF WARS! http://shadowkamen.tripod.com/ (Animated GIF website)
Send offlist e-mails to info_servo@...
Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Yahoo! Mobile. Try it now.