Re: [TalkAntietam] Re: South Mountain markers-Nagle's brigade
- Well, you BOTH have rather remarkable websites. I'm only sorry I hadn;t discovered Stephen's sooner.
When people talk about "digital history" (the buzzword du jour these days in college history departments), your sites represent the best of what the Web can offer.
----- Original Message ----
From: Brian Downey <bdowney@...>
Sent: Thursday, September 13, 2007 9:53:40 AM
Subject: [TalkAntietam] Re: South Mountain markers-Nagle's brigade
For the record, Stephen had all the monuments and tablets online on
Virtual Antietam long before I had any on AotW. Also, mine aren't
actually tablet images, though Stephen's are. Mine are text --
formatted to look like tablets -- so the content is Google-searchable
and I have tablets with text for those long lost from the actual
battlefield (based on Carman/Heth' s notes from the Archives). AotW
versions are also linked to maps and military units mentioned for
You want to look at what's actually on the field? Go see Stephen.
--- In TalkAntietam@ yahoogroups. com, Joseph Pierro <joseph_pierro@ ...>
>battlefiled on the AOTW site, but didn't realize someone had captured
> Thanks Steve! I knew of the full set of tablet images from Antietam
the remaining ones from outside of the park boundary.
Looking for a deal? Find great prices on flights and hotels with Yahoo! FareChase.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
No, YOU da man.
Actually I do appreciate the kind words. Another thought about the
differences in the two databases. Virtual Antietam is a simple keyword
search of the text of the markers and monuments. You gotta know what
you are looking for, because if you keyword search for "Maryland" and
the marker says, MD, you are out of luck. AotW, on the other hand, is
an actual relational database that will parse out specific narrow
So if I am at a book show and I need to find out if the 16th Alaska
Dogsled Team was at Antietam, I fire up AotW and it finds it for me. If
I want to see what the area behind the marker looks like I use Virtual
I didn't find the data for the 'lost markers' at the archives. I got a
folder from Jane Custer that has pictures of every marker on the field.
She has photos of a few markers that are gone, an example being the one
that used to be on the house near Middle Bridge.
In some of my the postcards and battlefield photos I have seen missing
markers and markers that have been moved. There is a great Burgan
postcard that shows the three markers for Sedgwick's brigades placed
just north of the 15th MA monument. They are now south of it down the
hill. I also have a photos of an old marker that used to be in front of
Old Simon. It looks like it is the congressional act creating the
cemetery. There is no marker there now. And there used to be a marker
just south west of the NJ monument.
On Thursday, September 13, 2007, at 09:53 AM, Brian Downey wrote:
> For the record, Stephen had all the monuments and tablets online on
> Virtual Antietam long before I had any on AotW. Also, mine aren't
> actually tablet images, though Stephen's are. Mine are text --
> formatted to look like tablets -- so the content is Google-searchable
> and I have tablets with text for those long lost from the actual
> battlefield (based on Carman/Heth's notes from the Archives). AotW
> versions are also linked to maps and military units mentioned for
> cross reference.
> You want to look at what's actually on the field? Go see Stephen.