- "It is interesting to note that (as Dr. Abbott has shown) the fourth Gospel inserts or refers to every incident given in St. Mark which St. Luke has passed over."
I came across the above on the online Catholic Encyclopedia
To what work is this referring?
Can someone tell me more?
- - - - -
Timothy M. Lewis
Cranbourne, VIC 3977
Part-time Greek Tutor at Whitley College,
Melbourne College of Divinity, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.1.371 / Virus Database: 267.14.14/222 - Release Date: 1/5/06
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
- Check the bibliography at the bottom of the article. I
would assume that the scholar is:
EDWIN ABBOTT, Notes on New Testament Criticism
Here's the full bibliography:
The literature on Papias is of overwhelming quantity.
Every introduction to the New Testament, every book on
the Fourth Gospel mentions him. The best discussion in
English is LIGHTFOOT'S Essays on Supernatural
Religion, reprinted from the Contemporary Review
(London, 1889); on the preface see especially ZAHN,
Forschungen, VI (1900); on the two Johns, DRUMMOND,
EZRA ABBOTT, CAMERLUNCH, and others on the Gospel of
St. John; for the view that the Apostle was not at
Ephesus but only the presbyter, HARNACK, Gesch. der
altchr. Litt., II (1897), and (making the presbyter
the beloved disciple) DELFF, Gesch d. Rabbi Jesus
(Leipzig, 1889); IDEM, Das vierte Evang.
wienderhergestellt; IDEM, Neue Beitrage zur Kritik und
Erklarung des vierten Ev. (both at Husum, 1890);
SANDAY, The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel (Oxford,
1905); BOUSSET, Offenbarung d. Joh. (Leipzig, 1896);
also ZAHN, loc. cit.; STANTON, The Gospels as Hist.
Documents, I (1903); CHAPMAN, John the Presbyter
(Oxford, 1911); on the supposed martyrdom of St. John,
DE BOOR, Neue Fragmente des Papias in Texteu. Unters.,
V, II (1888); DELEF, loc. cit; CHAPMAN, loc. cit;
SCHWARTZ, Ueber den Tod der Sohne Zebedaei (infavour
of the martyrdom, Berlin 1904); against are ARMITAGE
ROBINSON, The Historical Character of St. John's
Gospel (London, 1908); EDWIN ABBOTT, Notes on New
Testament Criticism (London, 1906); for a general
account of Papias, see BARDENHEWER, Gesch. der
altkirchl. Litt., I (Freiburg, 1902), who gives
sufficient references to older books and articles;
more in RICHARDSON'S Synopisis (Buffalo, 1887). On St.
John in Irenaeus, CHAPMAN, Papias on the Age of our
Lord in Journal of Theol. Studies, IX (Oct., 1907),
33; GUTJAHR, Die Glaubwurdigkeit des irenaischen
Zeugnisses (Graz, 1904); LEWIS, The irenaeus testimony
to the Fourth Gospel (Chicago, 1908); on the Chiliasm
of Papias, ATZBERGER, Gesch. der christl. Eschatologie
(Freiburg, 1896); GRY, Le millenarisme (Paris, 1904;
New York, 1899).
--- Tim Lewis <tim_lewis@...> wrote:
> "It is interesting to note that (as Dr. Abbott has
> shown) the fourth Gospel inserts or refers to every
> incident given in St. Mark which St. Luke has passed
> I came across the above on the online Catholic
> To what work is this referring?
> Can someone tell me more?
> - - - - -
> Timothy M. Lewis
> Cranbourne, VIC 3977
> Part-time Greek Tutor at Whitley College,
> Melbourne College of Divinity, Melbourne, Victoria,
Ph.D., History, U.C. Berkeley
(Doctoral Thesis: "Food as Synecdoche in John's Gospel and Gnostic Texts")
M.A., History of Science, U.C. Berkeley
B.A., English Language and Literature, Baylor University
Assistant Professor Horace Jeffery Hodges
Department of English Language and Literature
136-701 Anam-dong, Seongbuk-gu
Dr. Sun-Ae Hwang and Dr. Horace Jeffery Hodges
Sehan Apt. 102-2302