Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Facts about the establishment of Catholicate of east

Expand Messages
  • Dr. Leena George Thekkekara
    In Malankara Syrian Church, the throne of Catholicose is a topic of debate, even after the elapse of one century. Let us have a glimpse on the facts of this
    Message 1 of 40 , Oct 2, 2012
    In Malankara Syrian Church, the throne of Catholicose is a topic of debate, even after the elapse of one century. Let us have a glimpse on the facts of this subject.


    At the dawn of Christianity in the 1st century, there were two great political powers that stood against each other in the Near and the Middle East; the Roman (Byzantine) Empire and the Empire of the Parthians (or Sassanaid Persians since the early 3rd century). This traditional enmity had a determining influence on the history of that area for centuries. The border line between these rival empires divided the landscape of Mesopotamia with the Syriac speaking population on either side. The great city of Antioch was where a Christian presence appeared for the first time outside Palestine, the capital of the Syrian Province, in the Eastern part of the Roman Empire. The Patriarchs of the city of Antioch have special importance in the history of Christianity as it was here St. Peter, the chief of the Apostles, established his Apostolic See in AD 37. Antioch and regions east of it were placed under the care of the Patriarch of Antioch and all the East. (The Christian Church laws that took shape in the early era through regional and ecumenical councils reaffirmed the ecclesiastical jurisdictions of the Patriarchs of Antioch, Alexandria and Rome).

    In the first Synod at Nicaea, in AD 325, three Global Centers of Church were present and was further legalized in Universal Church arena. Again, in the second Synod in Constantinople in AD 381, a forth Center of the Universal Church was established, which was Constantinople. Thus Christians living in the four human inhabited centers of the world then, such as East Europe, West Europe, Asia and Africa were being religiously administered by four dedicated Patriarch or Pope. In the first Synod in Nicaea itself, Syrian Orthodox Patriarch of Antioch was given the jurisdiction of Antioch and all the East (complete Asian continent).

    Now let us look more in-depth about Catholicose in the global perspective of the Antiochan Syriac Orthodox Church. It was hard for the Antiochan Syrian Orthodox Church members in the Persian Empire to consecrate Bishops from Antioch. Accordingly, the Patriarch of Antioch through His delegate Bishop Mor Marutha consecrated the Bishop of Seleucia (a place near the present Bagdad, Iraq), MOR ISHAQ (Issac) as the first �Catholicose of Seleucia� in AD 410. Catholicos of Seleucia acted as the Ambassador of the Patriarch of Antioch, in the Persian Empire, with some exclusive privileges to consecrate bishops on behalf of the Patriarch. After 88 years (i.e. on AD 498), a Nestorian supporter Bersaumma betrayed then Catholicose of Seleusia to the Persian Emperor Feroz. The Catholicose was assassinated and a Nestorian was elevated as the Nestorian Catholicose of Seleucia and Patriarch of Babylon. This is the history of the decline of Catholicose of Seleucia and regeneration of Nestorianism.

    Even though the Church in Persia had officially accepted Nestorianism, a substantial group of Christians in Mosul, Niniveh and Tigris (Tagrit) continued to keep their loyalty to the old faith. A few decades later the Orthodox wing of the Church in Persia that continued to be under the Syrian Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch & all the East, got reorganized under St. Ya`qub Burdono and installed St. Ahudemmeh as 'The Great Metropolitan of the East', but he too found it difficult to discharge his ecclesiastical duties smoothly. However by the 7th century the situation changed for the better which finally led to the formation of an office of the �Maphrianate of the East� at Tigrit in Tigris, after an ecclesiastical power vacuum for 131 years. In AD 629, the Patriarch of Antioch and all the East H.H. Moran Mor Ignatius Athanasius �I (AD 595 -631) consecrated Marutha, a Monk in Mar Mathai Dayara (south east of Mosul) as the first �Maphriana of Tigris�. Later the centre of the Maphrianate was shifted from Tigrit to St. Mathew�s Dayro in the city of Mosul in Iraq. This Maphrianate continued functioning well for 1231 years. But in the context of the declining position in Iraq due to the changing geo-political situations, the Maphrianate became more of a nominal position in nature and hence in AD 1860 the Synod chaired by the Antiochan Patriarch, H.H. Moran Mor Ignatius Yacoob II decided to abolish it. The records of this Synod decisions are available in the library of Kurkuma Monastry or St.Hananyo�s Monastery in Turkey.


    Let us see in detail the position of Catholicose in the Malankara perspective. In 1912 the �throne (?)� of Catholicose was established in Malankara by the enthronement of Murimattom Mar Ivanios Paulose as the First Catholicose of the Indian Orthodox faction with the name Mor Basliose Paulose I by the already deposed Patriarch of Antioch Mor Ignatius Abdul Masih II, which has no legal, ecclesiastical or canonic validity. Besides, this consecration of Catholicose, breached basic canonic tradition that there should be the presence of minimum of three Major Bishops. However he passed away on 1913. His reign lasted only for 1 year.

    Then there was a power vacuum for the Indian Orthodox faction for 12 years.

    In 1925 Mor Philoxenos Vakathanum was consecrated as the second Catholicose with the name Mor Basaliose Geevarghese I. This consecration also was not canonical due to the absence of Patriarch of Antioch and the presence of only two Metrapolitans (canonically minimum three Metrapolitans are required for consecration). He passed away on 1928. His reign lasted for 3 years.

    In 1929, Mor Gregorios was consecrated as the third Catholicose with the name Mor Basaliose Geevarghese II. This consecration also was not canonical due to the absence of Patriarch of Antioch and the presence of only two Metrapolitans. In 1957, H. H. Moran Mor Ignatius Yacoob III was consecrated as Patriarch of Antioch. Since He had directly witnessed the problems of Malankara Church during his long stay in Manjanikara Dyara, took the initiative to reconcile the division in the Malankara Church. The Patriarch expressed his willingness for reunification of the two factions of Malankara Church in his first Kalpana, when all the court verdicts were in favour of the Jacobite faction. Accordingly, in the year 1958 Patriarch expressed his willingness to consecrate a Catholicose in Malankara. This paved the way for peace in Malankara. Eight years later, the Catholicose Geevarghese II passed away (1964), but in a peaceful atmosphere. His reign lasted for 35 years.

    In 1964, Mor Augen Thimothios was consecrated as the Fourth Catholicose, with the name Mor Basaliose Ougen I, by the Antiochan Syrian Orthodox Patriarch, H. H. Moran Mor Ignatious Yacob III with all his ecclesiastical blessings. Thus for the first time a canonical Catholicate was established in India.

    Now let us see the Statement of Oath taken by Mor Basaliose Augen I, during his consecration as Catholicose:

    �I the feeble and meek Ougen Mor Themothios, chosen for ecclesiastical office of the Catholicose, confess my belief before this synod and before the Head of this synod, H. H. Moran Mor Ignatius Yacob III, Patriarch of Antioch and all the East, that the Patriarch is my Head, that I accept from St. Peter the Head of the Holy Apostles up to your Holiness all the canonical Patriarchs who have reigned on your Holiness�s throne and all those who come after Your Holiness. Once again, I repeat my canonical connection with the Holy throne of Antioch. I swear that I shall not depart from this solemn Oath. (Note: This has been published in �Sabha Varthakal� dated February 9, 1973 printed in Good Hope Printers, Kottayam and �Illustrated weekly of India, Vol.XLVI-51 dated December 21-27, 1975).

    But, Mor Basaliose Augen I, breached his oath systematically. He started preaching on the throne of St. Thomas and had been trying to segregate the Church from the See of Antioch. This has been reported to H. H. Moran Mor Ignatius Yacob III, Patriarch of Antioch. The Patriarch advised him several times to correct himself. But the Catholicose ignored his requests. Finally, Patriarch, H. H. Moran Mor Ignatious Yacob III send the Catholicose a memo with a warning note on January 10, 1975, which was almost 11 years after his consecration as Catholicose. But the Catholicose continuously ignored the Patriarch. Eventually, the Patriarch ex-communicated the Catholicose Mor Basaliose Augen I on August 21, 1975.

    On September 7, 1975, H.H. Moran Mor Ignatius Yacob III consecrated Metropolitan Paulose Mor Philoxenos as the Catholicose of Malankara Syrian Orthodox Church with the name Mor Basaliose Paulose II. He underwent several trials and tribulations. Even he was pushed out from his own Aramana at Moovattupuzha. But the Catholicose demonstrated our Lord Jesus Christ�s forgiveness and he walked away. He later started residing in Piramadom Dayara and was leading a simple and ascetic life of fasting and prayers. He passed away on September 1, 1996. He believed Antioch as the spring of grace (kripayude uravidam). Thus he (Malankarayude Prakashagopuram) reigned the Malankara Antiochan Syrian Orthodox Church for 21 years, which was the most difficult time in our church�s history.

    On November 6, 1996 Malankara Church selected Metropolitan Geevarghese Mor Gregorios (Perumbally Pally Thirumeni) as Malankara Jacobite Church Episcopal President. But on February 22, 1999, He passed away.
    Metropolitan Thomas Mor Dionysius became the Malankara Jacobite Church Episcopal President. All the efforts of peace failed. Finally on December 27, 2000, Metropolitan Thomas Mor Dionysius was selected for the position of Catholicose of Malankara Jacobite Church. Eventually on July 26, 2002, he was consecrated as the Catholicose of Malankara Jacobite Church. He too is undergoing trials, tests, tribulations and persecutions. The Indian Orthodox faction has given more than 425 cases against Him in the Court, whereas he in return didn�t give a single case against the Indian Orthodox faction. He too has been demonstrating our Lord Jesus Christ�s forgiveness. It is no wonder our H.H. Moran Mor Patriarch have bestowed up on him, the title � �Jacob Burdana of Malankara�. By the grace of God even at the age of 84, H.B. Catholicose is victoriously leading and guiding our Malankara Church with dedication, hard work, love, tolerance, fasting and prayers under the Holy See of Antioch where our beloved patriarch H.H. Moran Mor. Ignatius Zakka Iwas I reigns.

    In Episcopal dignity the Catholicos ranks second to the Patriarch. As His Holiness�s deputy, the Catholicos preside over the provincial Holy Synod. He and all the clergy of the faithful in India pledge loyalty to the Patriarch of Antioch, the supreme spiritual authority of the Syriac Orthodox Church throughout the world.

    By Dr. Leena George Thekkekara
  • Zach George Arapura
    Dr.Leena and others interested, It is not my job to point out your non sequiturs but I wonder how you inferred that I believe that there won t be any change
    Message 40 of 40 , Nov 3, 2012
      Dr.Leena and others interested,

      It is not my job to point out your non sequiturs but I wonder how you inferred that I believe "that there won't be any change in policies of an institute as long as it is run by the same sect of people" because I would have thought that it is emphatically clear from my sentence you quoted that "policies do change". What I was merely pointing out was that the nature of the University i.e., ethos remained Protestant. And from your earlier messages I gather that you believe MSOT seminary is "better off being on its own". While I don't entirely agree with that, I believe your opinion stems from the concern over the Protestant nature of University. In the `Kalpana' you quoted in one of your previous messages, HH the Patriarch asked for clarification to Baselios Augen I for "affiliating the Seminary to the Serampore University of Culcutta[sic], which is well known as a protestant university". To me it looks like His Holiness was concerned over the Protestant nature of the University to which a Syriac Orthodox Seminary is affiliated to. And as far as I know their ethos haven't changed.

      I thank you for taking the trouble to contact the proper authorities regarding the syllabus and affiliation. Shri Joshy Pauls clarification was similar. Though what I learnt from my own enquiry was that before the BD course commences a foundation course on our faith, liturgy and addenda is taught to the priests-in-training of our church and after completing that they advance to the regular 4 year BD program with a University prescribed syllabus with no dilutions. So, unless you have categorized everything that is being taught at the MSOT seminary as syllabus my information is inaccurate.

      The Orthodox seminary was affiliated in 1964 and 38 years have passed since His Holiness asked for clarifications in 1974. I do understand that we were pre occupied with the schism for many years. Surely it is time to think, at least, of a Theological University with Orthodox ethos as a long term goal. You asked, "Who told you that they are not planning it?" Well, do you know if there is any long-term vision of that sort? Usually it has been our practice to announce things we plan to do with a lot of hue and cry and I didn't hear about this one. Maybe I wasn't paying attention when it was being announced. I am well aware of our "achievements" as you put it and I am not criticizing any of it rather I congratulate our HB Thomas I, Catholicose of India, and all the associated people on their steadfastness to bring glory to our Church. But I do hope it didn't come at the cost of our spiritual growth.

      Theological studies in India are not easy and the Church has a certain responsibility to make it better. From what I understand MSOT seminary doesn't offer Masters or Doctoral courses. Maybe we can start from there. Maybe my opinion to put Theological University on a higher priority as one of our Church's goals is a minority one and, as you put it, is not one which is passed by the Holy Synod with "two third majorities". But even in a top-down structure like ours I believe the voice of an ordinary faithful do matter and airing opinions on this forum gives me an opportunity to engage in meaningful opinion building process.

      Lastly on a personal note, my query whether you were related to me was to make us not "strangers". Though a simple yes or no might have sufficed, I do understand your reservations for giving out personal information even though I gave out my personal information. But being 22 and a student (oops! I did it again: P) makes me relax over my own privacy concerns.

      Hope I've been polite, courteous and clear.

      Zach George Arapura
      Member# 3083
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.